I have been following with both interest and some irritation, a discussion (in the comments) on the estimable Blog Cranmer. I don't happen to agree with what has been written by the Rev Dr Mullen on this occasion, concerning the decision by the Church in Wales to consecrate women bishops. Frankly, if you ordain women or men, then you have to accept that they can also be consecrated into the bishopric. The fact is that there is a considerable body of evidence to suggest that this is exactly what happened in the Early Church before the Council of Nicea.
My ire has, however, been raised by the supercilious and often patronising comments being made there by a number of people who are apparently converts to Roman Catholicism and one or two others who consider that Wikipedia articles give them all the information they need on the theology of the Anglican Church. One or two, in particular, simply ignore every argument they cannot refute with anything other than "Rome says" and have even managed to presume to tell some Orthodox Jews what a fundamentalist Rabbi has written as if it was the mainstream of Jewish thinking. The irony is that these trolls seem to be blissfully unaware of the row in Germany between the rigidly anti-women in the Church and the modernisers which has got the Bishop of Limburg (among others) into the headlines.
The problem with the RCC is that it cannot decide whether it is an inclusive church, or an exclusive one. In fact, it often seems that the "Church" is the clergy and the laity are merely "sheep" for the clergy to herd. There is no open discussion on anything, it is a case of "my way, or the highway" on everything. If that is how you like your faith to be, then fine, go there, but I am very, very certain, that is NOT how Christ intended it to be.
Reading the comments of the pro-RCC commenters as they denigrate everything about everyone else's faith, but particularly the Anglican Churches, one could be forgiven for wondering which century they live in. Prime among their arguments at the moment is the validity of Anglican Ordination. According to one man who seems to spend all day digging around Wikipedia, the Anglican Church 'lost' the Apostolic Succession in its Episcopacy at the Reformation. His source is a Wiki article that points to the Anglo-Catholic Revival in the 19th Century where some, concerned at the suggestion that the 'touch of the Apostles' had been lost, invited some Dutch Old Catholic Bishops to take part in their consecrations. In fact, this article and the event it describes, is not the entire picture. Even after the Papal excommunication of all England, there were still some 36 Bishops in post who continued the traditions of ordination and consecration. Read the 1662 Prayer Book Ordination Services and you see this clearly.
Even during the abomination of the Puritan and Presbyterian years of the Commonwealth, Cromwells efforts to expunge the Bishopric from Anglican life failed. Enough bishops went into hiding and exile to preserve the Apostilic link to restore it to the church as it emerged from the excesses of the Puritans, Iconoclasts and Presbyterians. As the Presbyterian and Puritan grip slackened on the church (it still remains in the form of Parliament's having a say in its governance) the true 'Catholic' nature of the church was able to re-emerge. One of the ironies that seems to have escaped one of the more rabid RCC commenters, is that the Archdiocese of Sydney is trying to revert to the Puritan ideas of the 17th Century, yet this man holds it up as an example of the church as a "woman free church".
Rome insists that to become a valid Church the Anglicans MUST bow the knee to the Popes, accept all Roman dogma and doctrine and the revalidation of all the Ordinariate. The claims of 'superiority' all hinge on one line from the Gospel of St Mark (taken completely out of context since, if read with what goes before and after and in the context of all the other gospels it is clearly a reference to all the faithful) and what, in the Vulgate, is refered to as the "Synod of Jerusalem" in which James (The brother of Christ) expounds at length on how he will implement Peter's directives in 'his' See (Jerusalem). The fact there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that any of the Apostles who out lived Peter, ever acknowledged his successor as exercising the authority they ascribe to Peter, is simply ignored or brushed aside.
The Dogma of Papal Infallibility is a major sticking point for many. In fact, it refers only to matters where the Pope speaks "ex-cathedra" and any such proclamation must pass three "tests". In fact it is usually a declaration made after years of preparation and study by a team set up for the purpose. It merely has the Pope's name on it. There are many arguments about where it originated, but the fact is that, as a 'dogma' it is of very recent date - the First Vatican Council in fact. I, for one, reject it as a doctrine or as a dogma, just as I reject utterly the claims to secular directions from the clergy. Yes, they are obliged (indeed, as a man in a Licensed ministry, I am as well) to point out error, and to give advice on ethics, morality and so on of various secular matters, but this must be limited. One has only to look at the abuse of power by RCC bishops and clergy throughout the centuries where they have had secular authority as well as sacred duties to see where that leads.
Ireland is only now emerging from the crushing yoke imposed by their Roman clergy and bishops who systematically abused their powers in orphangaes, care homes and 'correction' houses for unmarried girls. On the one hand the girls were punished for falling pregnant, and on the other women were prevented from reporting abuse, rape and the forcible removal of their offspring by the church. Yes, that's an encouraging record for a country that accepted the rule of the Roman Curia as trumping their own Parliament. Nor is this abuse an isolated case. One of the major reasons the English bishops went with Henry VIII when he broke with Rome was the abuse of the law. Clergy were not subject to the law of the land, and even murder could be committed with impunity, secure in the knowledge that, as a person subject to the 'Canon' law rather than the King's Justice' you would be secure in your monastery or carted off to Rome - the pepers conveniently lost on the way - to carry on as before. We have seen the echoes of this in the pedophile scandals that have rocked the RCC in almost every country in the last 20 yeasrs. The RCC knew what was happening, but refused to offer up the abusers to secular authorities and then victimised the victims by threatening them into silence.
Yes, the RCC and its authoritarian vision on the world and the faith is inspiring. Not. If it were as Christian as it claims to be it would embrace all those outside it, welcoming them to the sacraments, and not excluding them. It chooses to exclude - unless you bow the knee to the Pope. I therefore reject utterly it's claims of supremacy in matters of teaching any part of the faith I find in the Gospels. The Curia cannot shake off the abuses of power by the de Medici Popes, or the Borgias or a number of others. It cannot convince me that it has always held to the 'true' faith when at least three of the 4th Century Popes were Gnostics and followers of Arianism.
The current Bishop of Rome, Francis I, is a breath of fresh air. He refuses to live in the Imperial palace and stays in a Guest House, but he is surrounded by Cardinals, Archbishops and Bishops who do not share his vision, or share his ideals. These are the real 'powers' in Rome and it has nothing to do with "faith' and everything to do with "power" of a very secular kind. The situation here in Germany with the scandal unfolding in the Limburg Diocese is far more typical than the example of Francis. That saddens me. It also angers me when I am faced with arrogant assertions of Rome's holding the only valid authority to the Christian faith.
I hope and pray that Francis I will be protected by the Holy Spirit and be able to overthrow the Old Regime in Rome to make his church more inclusive and less elitist. I pray for it, but I doubt he will be allowed to. In the meantime I will continue to worship as an Old Catholic and Anglican wherever I find myself. My faith does not depend on the approval, or otherwise, of the Pope or any of his minions. It centres on Christ and God and the church provides me with a vehicle through which to grow in faith and to share that with others. Over the years I have learned not to say something will 'never' happen or that I will 'never' change my view, but this is one issue where it will take a revelation like that experienced by Saul of Tarsus on the road to Damascus.
Tuesday, 17 September 2013
Friday, 13 September 2013
Unrest in Rome ...
The big story in this part of Germany is the revolt against the autocratic style of the Bishop of Limburg. It is a reflection of a much larger and wider revolt happening within the Roman Catholic Church here, with the people in the pews wanting changes to the church Rome, The Curia and the 'traditionalist' clergy refuse to allow. It may surprise some in the UK who love to bash the CofE about 'disunity' over many issues, to learn that there are a lot of Roman Catholics - some suggest a majority - who want married clergy, women clergy and a power structure that includes the 'Lay Voices'. At present it is almost a case of it doesn't matter what the Laity think or want, the Bishop and Clergy are the 'Church' and what they say goes.
As someone used to the British Press and some of the more 'Catholic' members of the CofE always criticising the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Church for not being dogmatic about some issues, or for being too 'liberal' in others, it is interesting to see that Rome has its problems as well. It is ironic that many of those who have 'jumped ship' from Anglicanism and 'gone to Rome' may find themselves too traditionalist even for the majority of Roman Catholics in the not too distant future.
What the row in Limburg is revealing is that the Roman Catholic Church in Germany is torn by these arguments. It is haemoraging people, revenues are falling faster than they can adjust, churches are having to be closed and even given up to other denominations. In the midst of all this, the last Pope appointed a hardline academic as Bishop of Limburg and his first action was to build himself a new HQ, ostensibly at a cost of €2 million. Unfortunately, the real cost has run out at €10 million at a time when they have had to close a large number of churches. The Dean of Frankfurt revolted over it and now we have petitions going round calling for the Bishop to either step down or to be more 'Open' and the submit to the will of his Synod. As a 'traditionalist' he seems incapable of admitting he's alienated almost everyone, or that he has made a mistake or two. In his mind he is the Bishop, he answers only to the Pope and, within his diocese, he is the sole authority.
We now even have the German Cardinals and Bishops trying desperately not to take sides, but some of the hardline traditionalists have already broken ranks and made some very unfortunate interventions. In the meantime, Roman Catholics are taking one of three options. Leaving the faith, changing to the Lutheran or Old Catholics or another, or continuing going to Mass, but refusing to pay the Church Tax. The hardline Bishops have sent round letters saying anyone in the last category must be refused communion, and there are rumblings about anyone in the other two categories as well.
None of this, of course, addresses the other issues Rome refuses to discuss, women in ministry, married priests and the role of the laity in the government of the Church itself. The feeling here is that Rome must change, must address these issues or become a rump, increasingly isolated from society. It promises to be an interesting power struggle under the current Pope ...
As someone used to the British Press and some of the more 'Catholic' members of the CofE always criticising the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Church for not being dogmatic about some issues, or for being too 'liberal' in others, it is interesting to see that Rome has its problems as well. It is ironic that many of those who have 'jumped ship' from Anglicanism and 'gone to Rome' may find themselves too traditionalist even for the majority of Roman Catholics in the not too distant future.
What the row in Limburg is revealing is that the Roman Catholic Church in Germany is torn by these arguments. It is haemoraging people, revenues are falling faster than they can adjust, churches are having to be closed and even given up to other denominations. In the midst of all this, the last Pope appointed a hardline academic as Bishop of Limburg and his first action was to build himself a new HQ, ostensibly at a cost of €2 million. Unfortunately, the real cost has run out at €10 million at a time when they have had to close a large number of churches. The Dean of Frankfurt revolted over it and now we have petitions going round calling for the Bishop to either step down or to be more 'Open' and the submit to the will of his Synod. As a 'traditionalist' he seems incapable of admitting he's alienated almost everyone, or that he has made a mistake or two. In his mind he is the Bishop, he answers only to the Pope and, within his diocese, he is the sole authority.
We now even have the German Cardinals and Bishops trying desperately not to take sides, but some of the hardline traditionalists have already broken ranks and made some very unfortunate interventions. In the meantime, Roman Catholics are taking one of three options. Leaving the faith, changing to the Lutheran or Old Catholics or another, or continuing going to Mass, but refusing to pay the Church Tax. The hardline Bishops have sent round letters saying anyone in the last category must be refused communion, and there are rumblings about anyone in the other two categories as well.
None of this, of course, addresses the other issues Rome refuses to discuss, women in ministry, married priests and the role of the laity in the government of the Church itself. The feeling here is that Rome must change, must address these issues or become a rump, increasingly isolated from society. It promises to be an interesting power struggle under the current Pope ...
Thursday, 12 September 2013
A Different Approach
The decision of one of Germany's highest courts, one which deals with matters of Constitutional matters, has handed down a decision today which addresses a very tricky issue. The case was brought because German law requires the schools to deliver a range of subjects and activities, including swimming. A 13 year old Muslim girl brought the case in order to avoid swimming lessons that take place in mixed groups. She (or her parents) argued that it was a breach of her freedom of religion to be compelled to swim with boys.
Her argument is one we have heard trotted out in the UK as well, but the German authorities argued that her being required to take part in educational activities (including swimming) did not infringe her religious freedoms. It all hinges on how you interpret the Quran's injunction (which is also in the Bible and probably came from there in the first place) to dress and behave 'modestly'. Somewhere in the last 1,000 years, this has been interpreted by Muslim clerics and scholars to mean that women must wear the head to toe coverings seen in the more fundamentalist societies or at least a head scarf seen in more relaxed societies. This girl evidently belongs to one of the more fundamentalist groups, but her argument also runs into a much larger and more problematic area - integration.
German law is quite clear, if you wish to live in Germany and hold German citizenship, you should be prepared to learn the language, respect German cultural institutions and practices and integrate into German society. You may keep your own cultural practices and religion, but cannot demand that the Germans must adopt them. The court has underscored this, ruling that the requirement to take part in the swimming lessons does NOT impact on her freedom of religious practice, and that she must take part in the swimming lessons. They did, however, compromise, and ruled that she may wear a 'Burkini" a loose full body swimming garment worn by women in the Middle East for swimming.
One thing the Germans are very sensitive to, is the creation of 'foreign' cultural ghettoes in their midst. It is something they see as threatening the structure of their society, and they are probably right. This is why Mrs Merkel is adamant that "Multi-Kulti" is dead. It has created ghettoes everywhere and allowed groups to defy all attempts to get them to integrate. The Germans don't like that, and I believe they are right. By all means celebrate where you have come from, and who you and your antecedents are - but if you want to live here, the language, the customs, the legal system, education and the culture is German. If you don't want to be a part of it, perhaps you need to rethink where you're living, working ...
How has the decision been recieved? By the majority of Muslims with acceptance, by the Salafists - ultra conservative and militant types - with anger, by the average German, with satisfaction. They're quite happy for Muslims to practice their religion, but when it comes to matters of custom, practice and the law there is only one law. And it's German.
Her argument is one we have heard trotted out in the UK as well, but the German authorities argued that her being required to take part in educational activities (including swimming) did not infringe her religious freedoms. It all hinges on how you interpret the Quran's injunction (which is also in the Bible and probably came from there in the first place) to dress and behave 'modestly'. Somewhere in the last 1,000 years, this has been interpreted by Muslim clerics and scholars to mean that women must wear the head to toe coverings seen in the more fundamentalist societies or at least a head scarf seen in more relaxed societies. This girl evidently belongs to one of the more fundamentalist groups, but her argument also runs into a much larger and more problematic area - integration.
German law is quite clear, if you wish to live in Germany and hold German citizenship, you should be prepared to learn the language, respect German cultural institutions and practices and integrate into German society. You may keep your own cultural practices and religion, but cannot demand that the Germans must adopt them. The court has underscored this, ruling that the requirement to take part in the swimming lessons does NOT impact on her freedom of religious practice, and that she must take part in the swimming lessons. They did, however, compromise, and ruled that she may wear a 'Burkini" a loose full body swimming garment worn by women in the Middle East for swimming.
One thing the Germans are very sensitive to, is the creation of 'foreign' cultural ghettoes in their midst. It is something they see as threatening the structure of their society, and they are probably right. This is why Mrs Merkel is adamant that "Multi-Kulti" is dead. It has created ghettoes everywhere and allowed groups to defy all attempts to get them to integrate. The Germans don't like that, and I believe they are right. By all means celebrate where you have come from, and who you and your antecedents are - but if you want to live here, the language, the customs, the legal system, education and the culture is German. If you don't want to be a part of it, perhaps you need to rethink where you're living, working ...
How has the decision been recieved? By the majority of Muslims with acceptance, by the Salafists - ultra conservative and militant types - with anger, by the average German, with satisfaction. They're quite happy for Muslims to practice their religion, but when it comes to matters of custom, practice and the law there is only one law. And it's German.
Friday, 6 September 2013
A Whitehall Agenda ...
I am saddened by the news that the Fire Brigades Union is once again balloting its members in the Fire and Rescue Services for a national strike. While I have never gone on strike, and do not believe that striking ever actually achieves a satisfactory long term solution for the workers, I have every sympathy for the underlying reasons for this one. Sadly, however, it will not achieve what the service needs, and it will simply facilitate what Whitehall really wishes to achieve. A return to the old "Insurance style" fire service provision - a service provided by a private contractor and no longer the responsibility of the Treasury and the Department for Communities and Local Government.
The 2004 Act makes full provision for it, and a strike will simply bring forward the date on which the moment when a Fire and Rescue Authority "contracts out" the provision of the fire and rescue services it is legally required to provide. The only requirement for such a contractor is that they "must employ fire fighters."
Why do I, a person who does not believe the Union has been "good" for the service, or that it has always had the best interests of the service at its core, have sympathy with their cause on this occasion?
It is this, the Minister for Fire has laid before Parliament, proposals to extend the retirement age of fire fighters, currently set at the completion of 30 years service at age 50 or age 55 for everyone below senior (Assistant Chief or higher) rank. There were very sound and solid reasons for setting these as the retirement age back in 1948, and they are even more valid today. The Fire Brigades Pension Scheme was set up to cover it, with the members paying into it at between 11 and 14% of salary for the 30 years. Some, who could not be expected to complete 30 years service by reason of having joined at age 30 or later, paid in more. Their employers, operating under Whitehall 'rules' did not invest a single penny of this money they have collected over the years, instead spending it on all manner of pet projects, such as parks, gardens, luxury offices, schools and 'social engineering' schemes.
Now they claim that falling income from contributions means they cannot afford to pay the fire service pensions. Of course not, they spent the money, and have padded and protected their own, but to hell with the fire fighters.
The Minister, advised by his Civil Service nonentities - the majority of whom are earning five and six times what a fire fighter earns and look forward to gold plated and protected pensions themselves - now want to make the fire fighters work to a minimum retirement age of 60 years. The Minister has told Parliament that "perhaps" 23% of the fire fighters will be unable to do this due to ill health, injury or age related inability to maintain the required level of fitness (described by a doctor in a report NOT released by the relevant department, as being equal to that required for Olympic competitors) that is virtually unachievable by the vast majority over 55. In fact, their own report estimates that a "worst case" scenario will result in over 90% of fire fighters being sacked between 55 and 60 because they cannot maintain the level of fitness required.
The Union rightly says that a national survey shows that a maximum of 12% of those affected MAY be "redeployed", which means the rest face the sack. Out you go, sorry, but we've no job for you - oh, and you can't get the full pension, and you'll have to wait until you're 60 ...
So what, you may say, this is only what every other worker faces. That is, to an extent true, but now we come to the reason the age limits were set in the first place. By the age of 50 a range of health issues start to bite. There is a very good reason that a large number of my former colleagues (all at least 10 years my junior) have had hip and knee replacements. Many have cartilage problems, many more, like me, have serious back problems which can only degenerate with age. I retired at 60, but I was in a non-operational post, and had to give up wearing Self Contained Breathing Apparatus at 56 (my doctor at the time actually asked me if I was trying to worsen my back condition) and I have a few other little problems which will worsen with age.
Reflexes are important in a fire fighter and with age these get slower, not a good thing in a tight corner. hearing loss, loss of smell, degenerating eyesight, all of these militate against someone continuing "in the job" beyond 55, and even now, many who should retire at 55 find themselves having to retire earlier because of these problems. Yet along comes a Minister and lays before Parliament a proposal to ignore all of this, all of it very, very well documented and verifiable, and extend the pension age for everyone in the service by 5 to 10 years. All to solve a problem the political classes (and I include the Civil Service in that) have created by their own stupidity and cupidity.
Sadly, I do believe the Whitehall agenda here is to remove the Fire and Rescue Service operational provision from public management to private. This change to the pension scheme is, in my view, simply a means to an end. By making it impossible to reach the pension age as a fire fighter, they hope that fewer people will stay on long enough to qualify for the full benefit. Those who don't will, as usual, be offered the opportunity to 'freeze' their contributions (the Treasury rubs its hands with glee!) or to 'transfer' them to whatever new scheme they can join - which will, undoubtedly offer far less benefit. By forcing the issue and provoking a strike Whitehall is laying the foundations for a "sell off" to their lobbyists and future directorship providers, of the Fire and Rescue Services. THis will do two things - it will remove the responsibility for the reduced service from Ministers and Civil Servants, and it will weaken, and even possibly destroy, the Fire Brigades Union, possibly the most militant and Left wing of all the remaining Unions.
Blair started this trend, the present government is merely seeing through what the Civil Servants already had in the pipeline. The Minister is either blind, or a fool if he continues down this path. No good will come of it for anyone, least of all the taxpayer.
The 2004 Act makes full provision for it, and a strike will simply bring forward the date on which the moment when a Fire and Rescue Authority "contracts out" the provision of the fire and rescue services it is legally required to provide. The only requirement for such a contractor is that they "must employ fire fighters."
Why do I, a person who does not believe the Union has been "good" for the service, or that it has always had the best interests of the service at its core, have sympathy with their cause on this occasion?
It is this, the Minister for Fire has laid before Parliament, proposals to extend the retirement age of fire fighters, currently set at the completion of 30 years service at age 50 or age 55 for everyone below senior (Assistant Chief or higher) rank. There were very sound and solid reasons for setting these as the retirement age back in 1948, and they are even more valid today. The Fire Brigades Pension Scheme was set up to cover it, with the members paying into it at between 11 and 14% of salary for the 30 years. Some, who could not be expected to complete 30 years service by reason of having joined at age 30 or later, paid in more. Their employers, operating under Whitehall 'rules' did not invest a single penny of this money they have collected over the years, instead spending it on all manner of pet projects, such as parks, gardens, luxury offices, schools and 'social engineering' schemes.
Now they claim that falling income from contributions means they cannot afford to pay the fire service pensions. Of course not, they spent the money, and have padded and protected their own, but to hell with the fire fighters.
The Minister, advised by his Civil Service nonentities - the majority of whom are earning five and six times what a fire fighter earns and look forward to gold plated and protected pensions themselves - now want to make the fire fighters work to a minimum retirement age of 60 years. The Minister has told Parliament that "perhaps" 23% of the fire fighters will be unable to do this due to ill health, injury or age related inability to maintain the required level of fitness (described by a doctor in a report NOT released by the relevant department, as being equal to that required for Olympic competitors) that is virtually unachievable by the vast majority over 55. In fact, their own report estimates that a "worst case" scenario will result in over 90% of fire fighters being sacked between 55 and 60 because they cannot maintain the level of fitness required.
The Union rightly says that a national survey shows that a maximum of 12% of those affected MAY be "redeployed", which means the rest face the sack. Out you go, sorry, but we've no job for you - oh, and you can't get the full pension, and you'll have to wait until you're 60 ...
So what, you may say, this is only what every other worker faces. That is, to an extent true, but now we come to the reason the age limits were set in the first place. By the age of 50 a range of health issues start to bite. There is a very good reason that a large number of my former colleagues (all at least 10 years my junior) have had hip and knee replacements. Many have cartilage problems, many more, like me, have serious back problems which can only degenerate with age. I retired at 60, but I was in a non-operational post, and had to give up wearing Self Contained Breathing Apparatus at 56 (my doctor at the time actually asked me if I was trying to worsen my back condition) and I have a few other little problems which will worsen with age.
Reflexes are important in a fire fighter and with age these get slower, not a good thing in a tight corner. hearing loss, loss of smell, degenerating eyesight, all of these militate against someone continuing "in the job" beyond 55, and even now, many who should retire at 55 find themselves having to retire earlier because of these problems. Yet along comes a Minister and lays before Parliament a proposal to ignore all of this, all of it very, very well documented and verifiable, and extend the pension age for everyone in the service by 5 to 10 years. All to solve a problem the political classes (and I include the Civil Service in that) have created by their own stupidity and cupidity.
Sadly, I do believe the Whitehall agenda here is to remove the Fire and Rescue Service operational provision from public management to private. This change to the pension scheme is, in my view, simply a means to an end. By making it impossible to reach the pension age as a fire fighter, they hope that fewer people will stay on long enough to qualify for the full benefit. Those who don't will, as usual, be offered the opportunity to 'freeze' their contributions (the Treasury rubs its hands with glee!) or to 'transfer' them to whatever new scheme they can join - which will, undoubtedly offer far less benefit. By forcing the issue and provoking a strike Whitehall is laying the foundations for a "sell off" to their lobbyists and future directorship providers, of the Fire and Rescue Services. THis will do two things - it will remove the responsibility for the reduced service from Ministers and Civil Servants, and it will weaken, and even possibly destroy, the Fire Brigades Union, possibly the most militant and Left wing of all the remaining Unions.
Blair started this trend, the present government is merely seeing through what the Civil Servants already had in the pipeline. The Minister is either blind, or a fool if he continues down this path. No good will come of it for anyone, least of all the taxpayer.
Thursday, 5 September 2013
A little knowledge ...
As the saying goes, a little knowledge is a dangerous thing. I was struck by this yesterday as I read the comments to a fairly comprehensive article about the hazards presented by certain 'designer' drugs currently returning to popularity among the younger scene. One commentator, responding to someone else who had, rather bluntly, pointed out that people who use drugs of unknown provenance, and die of the effects of bad reactions and impurities, are actually exercising a Darwinian "natural selection" response, came back with a rather ignorant attack about the first commentator dying nastily of cancer "caused by the GMO food you eat".
Recently there have been a number of serious scientific responses to the so-called ecologists and others who have campaigned to have Genetically Modified crops banned on the grounds they MAY cause diseases, spread uncontrollably or decimate insect populations. The irony does seem to escape them that virtually everything we eat today is "genetically modified" in some way. In fact, one reason we see so much Celiac Disease (sensitivity to gluten) is that the wheat we eat today is very different from that cultivated a thousand years ago, and different again from wheat grown even two hundred years ago. Modern wheat, has been developed by selective cross pollination of different grass species over the millennia since it was first cultivated. It is a hybrid, and today does not produce pollen and does not self propagate. However, the result of the wholesale transfer of genes from one grass species to another, and then from one hybridised wheat strain to another, is why the gluten content of modern wheat is high enough to cause allergies.
Another of the major causes of rising allergy sensitivities is pesticide usage. GM crops use far less of this, so the exposure is reduced in the consumer, which is not the case in the normal strains the campaigners don't want replaced. Once again, we hear of the Bio-foods being better and healthier, but, if you use natural fertilisers (cow droppings, pig droppings, etc., you are actually increasing the likelihood of spreading e-coli, listeria and a few other nasties including tetanus. Plus, not using pesticides (so-called natural pesticides are terribly inefficient), means that loss of crops to slugs, beetles, caterpillars and so on reduces yields and increases prices. Bio-food can never produce anything like the volumes of food required to feed the world's current population. Its exponents actually reveal either a naiveté or are concealing the fact they actually want to reduce world populations drastically and return the globe to their idealised vision of a perfect human/natural balance.
What the GM crop developers have done is splice in selected genetic material ( a technique really only possible in the last 40 or so years) to reduce the gluten content, make wheat more resistant to things like Ergot (a toxic fungus now known to have triggered the Salem Witch hunts), to attack by insects and drought. Once again, the hysteria by the anti-GM activists, fuelled by irresponsible headlines like "Frankenfoods given the go-ahead", and even more irresponsibly emotive reporting which highlighted "the risks" without pointing out that all the testing and all the trials had shown these to be almost non-existent was whipped to a frenzy. It followed exactly the same pattern as the anti-innoculation campaigns run by a small group of campaigners and based entirely on their own fear.
As a recent article I read on this subject points out, often the anti-campaigners have a hidden agenda. They are opposed to the commercial interests developing and marketing the GM foods, or the vaccines. They want a world filled with benevolent governments where everything is free to everyone, and hate commerce - so they attack the product on the grounds of "public concern for safety/the environment". The result, in the case of GM foods, is that genetically modified crops which could go a long way to alleviating the regular famines in Africa, are now universally banned from those countries that would reap the most benefit. Rice, which is very low in Vitamin A, but is a staple food in the Far East and many other countries is a major problem. However, the GM version, modified to produce the Vitamin A and address some other deficiencies, is banned, and not grown - ostensibly because of fears over its 'safety' but the reality is the political opposition to the US based firm which developed it.
There is no evidence to support the claims that eating GM foods can increase allergic reactions, rather the opposite, yet throughout Europe the "Greens" campaign against it on the grounds that it MIGHT. Likewise forty years of testing have failed to provide a link to cancer, but, again, the "Greens" shout loudly that one, very specially selective and now discredited trial by an anti-GM campaigner "proves" that there is such a risk. (The trial used specially bred rats that are very susceptible to tumours. They have been 'modified' so they will develop tumours and are generally used to test methods of controlling a tumour. And there must be an irony there, for an anti-GM campaigner to use a genetically modified rat to prove his case ...)
In almost all these campaigns fear is the driver for the wider majority. Few have more than a vague idea of what they are afraid of, or of precisely what is actually involved or modified. None I have met actually knew that the crops they were so keen to destroy don't self propagate, so cannot 'spread' across 'natural' plants and 'destroy the natural diversity'. The focus is always on the fact that some crops have been modified by splicing in segments of viral and bacterial genes, and their battle cry is always 'we don't know what will happen if it mutates'. Actually, the scientists and biologists do have a pretty good idea - that is what all the trials and tests are about. Nothing that can mutate into something dangerous ever leaves the lab now, the lessons of Thalidomide and a few others have been learned by the leading companies involved.
A little knowledge is a dangerous thing, but far too many people today think that they can become experts on a subject by consulting Wikipedia or some other 'source' that reinforces their views. Sadly, it is impossible to debate with these folk, and because the media are currently locked into sensationalism, poor fact checking and emotive reporting, this is a debate that isn't going to happen any time soon. Probably not before all the anti-campaigners have succeeded in triggering the next major famine.
Recently there have been a number of serious scientific responses to the so-called ecologists and others who have campaigned to have Genetically Modified crops banned on the grounds they MAY cause diseases, spread uncontrollably or decimate insect populations. The irony does seem to escape them that virtually everything we eat today is "genetically modified" in some way. In fact, one reason we see so much Celiac Disease (sensitivity to gluten) is that the wheat we eat today is very different from that cultivated a thousand years ago, and different again from wheat grown even two hundred years ago. Modern wheat, has been developed by selective cross pollination of different grass species over the millennia since it was first cultivated. It is a hybrid, and today does not produce pollen and does not self propagate. However, the result of the wholesale transfer of genes from one grass species to another, and then from one hybridised wheat strain to another, is why the gluten content of modern wheat is high enough to cause allergies.
Another of the major causes of rising allergy sensitivities is pesticide usage. GM crops use far less of this, so the exposure is reduced in the consumer, which is not the case in the normal strains the campaigners don't want replaced. Once again, we hear of the Bio-foods being better and healthier, but, if you use natural fertilisers (cow droppings, pig droppings, etc., you are actually increasing the likelihood of spreading e-coli, listeria and a few other nasties including tetanus. Plus, not using pesticides (so-called natural pesticides are terribly inefficient), means that loss of crops to slugs, beetles, caterpillars and so on reduces yields and increases prices. Bio-food can never produce anything like the volumes of food required to feed the world's current population. Its exponents actually reveal either a naiveté or are concealing the fact they actually want to reduce world populations drastically and return the globe to their idealised vision of a perfect human/natural balance.
What the GM crop developers have done is splice in selected genetic material ( a technique really only possible in the last 40 or so years) to reduce the gluten content, make wheat more resistant to things like Ergot (a toxic fungus now known to have triggered the Salem Witch hunts), to attack by insects and drought. Once again, the hysteria by the anti-GM activists, fuelled by irresponsible headlines like "Frankenfoods given the go-ahead", and even more irresponsibly emotive reporting which highlighted "the risks" without pointing out that all the testing and all the trials had shown these to be almost non-existent was whipped to a frenzy. It followed exactly the same pattern as the anti-innoculation campaigns run by a small group of campaigners and based entirely on their own fear.
As a recent article I read on this subject points out, often the anti-campaigners have a hidden agenda. They are opposed to the commercial interests developing and marketing the GM foods, or the vaccines. They want a world filled with benevolent governments where everything is free to everyone, and hate commerce - so they attack the product on the grounds of "public concern for safety/the environment". The result, in the case of GM foods, is that genetically modified crops which could go a long way to alleviating the regular famines in Africa, are now universally banned from those countries that would reap the most benefit. Rice, which is very low in Vitamin A, but is a staple food in the Far East and many other countries is a major problem. However, the GM version, modified to produce the Vitamin A and address some other deficiencies, is banned, and not grown - ostensibly because of fears over its 'safety' but the reality is the political opposition to the US based firm which developed it.
There is no evidence to support the claims that eating GM foods can increase allergic reactions, rather the opposite, yet throughout Europe the "Greens" campaign against it on the grounds that it MIGHT. Likewise forty years of testing have failed to provide a link to cancer, but, again, the "Greens" shout loudly that one, very specially selective and now discredited trial by an anti-GM campaigner "proves" that there is such a risk. (The trial used specially bred rats that are very susceptible to tumours. They have been 'modified' so they will develop tumours and are generally used to test methods of controlling a tumour. And there must be an irony there, for an anti-GM campaigner to use a genetically modified rat to prove his case ...)
In almost all these campaigns fear is the driver for the wider majority. Few have more than a vague idea of what they are afraid of, or of precisely what is actually involved or modified. None I have met actually knew that the crops they were so keen to destroy don't self propagate, so cannot 'spread' across 'natural' plants and 'destroy the natural diversity'. The focus is always on the fact that some crops have been modified by splicing in segments of viral and bacterial genes, and their battle cry is always 'we don't know what will happen if it mutates'. Actually, the scientists and biologists do have a pretty good idea - that is what all the trials and tests are about. Nothing that can mutate into something dangerous ever leaves the lab now, the lessons of Thalidomide and a few others have been learned by the leading companies involved.
A little knowledge is a dangerous thing, but far too many people today think that they can become experts on a subject by consulting Wikipedia or some other 'source' that reinforces their views. Sadly, it is impossible to debate with these folk, and because the media are currently locked into sensationalism, poor fact checking and emotive reporting, this is a debate that isn't going to happen any time soon. Probably not before all the anti-campaigners have succeeded in triggering the next major famine.
Wednesday, 4 September 2013
Now there's a surprise ...
Over the last couple of days I have been reading reports of cars being damaged in the City of London, by sunlight reflected and focused on them by a new building under construction there. The building, nicknamed the "Walkie-Talkie" has fully glazed facades on all four sides. The difference between this building and other fully glazed structures in the City is that it has a concave profile to its outer walls. Those of my readers who have, in a misspent youth, played with a shaving mirror, will know that the concave reflective surface has an interesting property when one gets it to reflect sunlight onto something at just the right focal distance.
It seems that the architect has managed to achieve exactly the right focal distance between his building and the parking spaces in that section of Fenchurch Street. The result is some very expensive damage to luxury cars parked there. If the reports I've read are correct, someone in the construction team noticed this some time ago - because the developers aren't putting up a fight about it. They just pay for the damage and hope you'll not make a fuss. Now that it has reached the press of course, the City has reacted, and closed the affected parking area. The worrying part is this, no one appears to be considering the affect walking along the pavement there may have on someone should the reflected light hit their eyes, or the impact of such intense heating on the structures nearby.
We have long known that tall buildings, their services, the tarmac and concrete roads and pavements and the reflected light can cause local 'weather anomalies' around them. It is equally well known that more tarmac, more buildings and paved surfaces, cause a rise in local temperatures and, when it rains, increase the 'run-off' raising the risks of flooding. Since antiquity it has been known (Archimedes is reported to have built a weapon on the principle) that a mirror big enough and with the right curvature, can focus light to an intensity sufficient to blind and burn soldiers and - according to ancient reports - set ships on fire. As far back as the 1960s experiments showed that banks of mirrors could focus light on a 'target' - usually an arrangement of tubes filled with liquid - the produce steam and generate electricity with a turbine, so we really shouldn't be surprised that a building focusing light onto parked cars can melt the plastic trim. The surprise is that it 'only' melted it. Those 1960s experiments showed you could actually melt metals with that rig. It wasn't dubbed a "solar furnace" for nothing.
This development raises an important question for me, and perhaps it should raise it for the professions as well. The question is this: Does no one carry out an analysis of the impact of creating a structure which reflects light onto adjoining properties and surfaces? It does sometimes seem that almost everything else is considered (often in isolation and by different 'specialists' who often don't consider anyone elses reports or work), yet I have, in the past, often been astonished that some highly qualified professionals don't understand (or see) some fairly basic issues which can, and do, impact on what they propose.
Hopefully this Archimedian Mirror building will draw attention to the need to think a lot more carefully about the way so many today ignore every other discipline and focus only on their own comfort zone of knowledge. From the press I understand the designer and the developer are trying to find ways to 'mitigate' the problem. I'd suggest its a little late, this should have been identified at the design stage. Any 'mitigation' is likely to introduce some new problem somewhere else.
It seems that the architect has managed to achieve exactly the right focal distance between his building and the parking spaces in that section of Fenchurch Street. The result is some very expensive damage to luxury cars parked there. If the reports I've read are correct, someone in the construction team noticed this some time ago - because the developers aren't putting up a fight about it. They just pay for the damage and hope you'll not make a fuss. Now that it has reached the press of course, the City has reacted, and closed the affected parking area. The worrying part is this, no one appears to be considering the affect walking along the pavement there may have on someone should the reflected light hit their eyes, or the impact of such intense heating on the structures nearby.
We have long known that tall buildings, their services, the tarmac and concrete roads and pavements and the reflected light can cause local 'weather anomalies' around them. It is equally well known that more tarmac, more buildings and paved surfaces, cause a rise in local temperatures and, when it rains, increase the 'run-off' raising the risks of flooding. Since antiquity it has been known (Archimedes is reported to have built a weapon on the principle) that a mirror big enough and with the right curvature, can focus light to an intensity sufficient to blind and burn soldiers and - according to ancient reports - set ships on fire. As far back as the 1960s experiments showed that banks of mirrors could focus light on a 'target' - usually an arrangement of tubes filled with liquid - the produce steam and generate electricity with a turbine, so we really shouldn't be surprised that a building focusing light onto parked cars can melt the plastic trim. The surprise is that it 'only' melted it. Those 1960s experiments showed you could actually melt metals with that rig. It wasn't dubbed a "solar furnace" for nothing.
This development raises an important question for me, and perhaps it should raise it for the professions as well. The question is this: Does no one carry out an analysis of the impact of creating a structure which reflects light onto adjoining properties and surfaces? It does sometimes seem that almost everything else is considered (often in isolation and by different 'specialists' who often don't consider anyone elses reports or work), yet I have, in the past, often been astonished that some highly qualified professionals don't understand (or see) some fairly basic issues which can, and do, impact on what they propose.
Hopefully this Archimedian Mirror building will draw attention to the need to think a lot more carefully about the way so many today ignore every other discipline and focus only on their own comfort zone of knowledge. From the press I understand the designer and the developer are trying to find ways to 'mitigate' the problem. I'd suggest its a little late, this should have been identified at the design stage. Any 'mitigation' is likely to introduce some new problem somewhere else.
Friday, 30 August 2013
Out of the mouths of babes ...
Sometimes one stumbles across some little thing when you are reading, that leaps off the page and tells you more, in a small insight than all the learned history of a period even hints at. One such moment leapt off the page as I read a book of short biographic memories of women who lived through the war years in different parts of Germany. One woman, now in her 80s recalled getting into trouble for repeating a 'prayer' doing the rounds at her school in early 1942.
It goes -
Lieber Gott, mach mich taub, (Dear God, make me deaf,
Dass ich nicht am radio schraub, [So] That I won't turn on the radio,
Lieber Gott, mach mich blind Dear God, make me blind,
Dass ich alles herrlich find. [so] That I think everything is good,
Bin ich taub, und bin ich blind, If I'm deaf and if I'm blind
Bin ich Adolf's liebstes Kind. Then I'm Adolf's most loved child.)
It speaks for itself that this was circulating among the children, and that it terrified their parents to hear it repeated in innocence. What it does show is that the fear of the Gestapo, or of informers, was a major factor in keeping the adult German population under control, but that there were still brave souls able to think up this sort of simple rhyme which children would learn and repeat. The line concerning the radio also tells a careful reader that the ordinary German wasn't only listening to the official channels controlled by Goebbels Propaganda Ministry as the lady who recorded this memory makes clear, describing how, have punished her daughter for repeating the above prayer, her mother would take the radio beneath the duvet on her bed at night, and tune it to the forbidden broadcasts from England.
From the memories of the women in this short collection, it soon becomes very clear that you had to be blind, and the majority certainly weren't, not to see that things were not the way Hitler and the media said they were. You had to be blind not to see the abuses around you, and to not be aware of the oppressive control exercised by threat, by punishment and ultimately by being sent to a Death Camp. Even so, some of the stories contain other little insights, of farmers hiding refugees, of priests and ordinary citizens hiding Jews in the full knowledge that, if exposed, they faced imprisonment or death.
That this little prayer was circulating as early as 1942 suggests also that it had begun circulating earlier than that. Sadly, as the stories make plain, many of the children who recited it probably didn't survive the bombing and destruction that followed.
It goes -
Lieber Gott, mach mich taub, (Dear God, make me deaf,
Dass ich nicht am radio schraub, [So] That I won't turn on the radio,
Lieber Gott, mach mich blind Dear God, make me blind,
Dass ich alles herrlich find. [so] That I think everything is good,
Bin ich taub, und bin ich blind, If I'm deaf and if I'm blind
Bin ich Adolf's liebstes Kind. Then I'm Adolf's most loved child.)
It speaks for itself that this was circulating among the children, and that it terrified their parents to hear it repeated in innocence. What it does show is that the fear of the Gestapo, or of informers, was a major factor in keeping the adult German population under control, but that there were still brave souls able to think up this sort of simple rhyme which children would learn and repeat. The line concerning the radio also tells a careful reader that the ordinary German wasn't only listening to the official channels controlled by Goebbels Propaganda Ministry as the lady who recorded this memory makes clear, describing how, have punished her daughter for repeating the above prayer, her mother would take the radio beneath the duvet on her bed at night, and tune it to the forbidden broadcasts from England.
From the memories of the women in this short collection, it soon becomes very clear that you had to be blind, and the majority certainly weren't, not to see that things were not the way Hitler and the media said they were. You had to be blind not to see the abuses around you, and to not be aware of the oppressive control exercised by threat, by punishment and ultimately by being sent to a Death Camp. Even so, some of the stories contain other little insights, of farmers hiding refugees, of priests and ordinary citizens hiding Jews in the full knowledge that, if exposed, they faced imprisonment or death.
That this little prayer was circulating as early as 1942 suggests also that it had begun circulating earlier than that. Sadly, as the stories make plain, many of the children who recited it probably didn't survive the bombing and destruction that followed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)