Josephus sent me a link recently to an article in Forbes Magazine. He added the comment, "this will push your buttons." I read the article with great interest. Written by their political and economics contributor, Peter Ferrara, he had just attended the seventh International Conference on Climate Change. As I said, his report, entitled, perhaps provocatively, "Sorry Global Warming Alarmists: The Earth is Cooling" makes very interesting reading.
The Conference looked at a wide range of issues including the acquisition, compilation and adjustment of data and its application by spin doctors, politicians and others. It also took a good hard look at the economic impacts of what is being proposed by those on the Global Warming side.
Let me state right up front that I am a sceptic with regard to most of the claims being made by the IPCC. I don't believe the science behind Anthropomorphic Global Warming is anywhere near settled and I certainly don't believe the "modelling" predictions for any of it. Why? Mainly because most of those pushing this story are not playing with either a full deck of cards or have agendas that make me deeply suspicious. As the old saw goes, if you want to know what is behind something: Follow the Money. Who benefits by pushing the current "AGW" mantra? Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth, Earth First and a plethora of windmill manufacturers, anti-nuclear agitators, solar panel makers and, of course, the 'Climate Scientist' Community who are being funded to the tune of billions for "research." As the recent "Climategate" email hacking showed, these vested interests are not afraid to use bully-boy tactics to make damned sure nothing which threatens their version of what is happening appears in print. That is enough, in itself, to make me suspicious.
Perhaps I've had rather too much time working with police investigators who have taught me the mantra: "Trust no one; Question everything; Check everything." And the more I've looked at this the more stands out as being "not quite right" about it all.
It seems to me that those who claim that cutting out oil, reducing our emissions (notably in the west only) will "prevent global warming" are living in a dream world. You might as well say something like "we can stop continental drift if we drive big wedges between the tectonic plates in the subduction zones." Among other things, these are the same folk who trot out the mantra that we need "localisation" of things like power generation, food supply and so on. In short, as another writer on this subject has stated, these folk want to live in small self-sustaining communities. The hate the industrial world, they hate the thought of having to travel outside of their environs to get anything. Many are city dwellers with a very idealised vision of life in small communities and of self-sufficiency. (I live in a small idyllic village on a mountain ridge. Self-sufficient? No. We are dependent for almost everything on outside supply and this village has been for the several hundred years its been here.)
The climate is changing. It has been changing for the whole of the Earth's existence and it is also cyclic. Many things influence it, things the IPCC chooses to ignore. One is that, in all of its history, the planet has spent 20% of its time in ice ages and the rest considerably hotter than it is now. Technically we are still in an ice age, Antarctica is frozen solid and it will require several thousand years for all of that to melt even if we do let the CO2 levels exceed Dr. Hansen's "catastrophe" threshold. One estimate for the melting of the entire Greenland Ice Sheet is that it would take a minimum of 15,000 years and therein lies another little question mark. When Eric the Red originally settled there around 990 AD, he was able to keep and breed cattle. Once the "Little Ice Age" started to bite (around 1600), that became impossible and remains so to this day.
There are a number of indicators that suggest the climate is actually in a cooling phase at present. Certainly, from the data I have had a chance to see, what leapt out at me was that the data was so heavily "adjusted" for this, that and the next thing, I might as well have wet my finger, stuck it in the air and selected a number that appealed to me. One source openly state that they ignore "lowest" temperatures in their datasets and average only the highest. To me that is a sham, and average includes the highest and the lowest. The trouble is, when you're looking at temperatures and you do that, you end up with a lower temperature than the IPCC claims for the last several decades.
One thing I do know, is that the drive from lobby groups and tree hugger types through the political machinery for "green" and "renewable" energy is costing jobs and increasing prices exponentially. The Greenpeace demand to impose a "bunker tax" on all shipping won't achieve anything other than to drive the cost of food even higher. Almost all of Europe and the UK is dependent on imported food, consumer goods and so on. Imposing surcharges on transport simply increases the cost. Friends of the Earth have produced a wonderful plan to replace all nuclear and coal fired power generation with wind farms and solar. Only problem, their numbers are based on a reduction of energy use and ignores the fact that simply to supply a part of India with solar power requires 1 million acres of solar panels. They also want to put these in a "desert" - which is only 4 million acres and is one of the few places where certain plants are cultivated.
We do have to take on board the fact that there was no idyllic past. Without mass production our present lifestyles are impossible, modern medicine would not exist and sharing and transfer of resources become impossible. Fine, let's have solar heating and power - but we must then accept the fact that extraction of the extremely rare and scarce minerals needed for their production are causing huge environmental damage in China, India and elsewhere. Wind Farms? OK, but distribution is tricky, so is guaranteeing the supply. Britain has the capacity to generate something like 30% of its energy with wind,ills, trouble is they are usually shunting power into the grid when its not required - and it can't be stored. What about battery powered cars? OK, but again, the batteries have a 5 years lifespan. Six if you're lucky. Again, they use some very exotic minerals - and you can't reuse, refurbish or recycle them ...
I agree entirely that we do need to change the way we use the Earth, its resources and care for the environment, but instead of throwing money into 'single issues' which address only a tiny fraction of the larger problem we should sit back, do a complete analysis and then target those things we need to do to adapt how and what we do for the future.
There is no simple answer, and there is certainly no magic bullet. returning to idyllic little village communities dependent on their own resources is not an option. Its time those who dream that dream where made to face reality.
Monday, 18 June 2012
Saturday, 16 June 2012
A Little Weekend Break
The Monk and Mausi will be back on Sunday. We're having a little break in the Westerwald, though we don't expect to run into any dwarfs, werewolves, vampires of any spelling, witches or other folk out of any of Terry Pratchett's books.
Pity, they would probably be rather fun ...
Pity, they would probably be rather fun ...
Friday, 15 June 2012
More on Marriage
I noted yesterday that Bishop Tim Ellis had made a stand on this issue. What was interesting was the responses. There were a very large number in support and a handful in opposition to his position. One of those quite rightly stated that the 'official' statement was simply quoting and restating the Church's own Canon Law on the matter.
To me, that is a part of the problem. Canon Law, like any other "law" is man-made. I accept that it is made in order to regulate and maintain certain principles and behaviours, but it is not immutable and it was certainly not God-given. Like any other "law," Canon Law can be revised, reviewed, amended or even repealed. The problem with the Church of England at present, is that the General Synod has forgotten this. A large part of it wants to make more Canon Law and certainly do not want to allow any part of it to be reviewed, revised or changed.
Some years ago I was part of a group setting up a Server's Guild. One of our number, a lawyer, drafted a constitution for it. It was a masterpiece, it set out clearly what we were, what our aims were and how we regulated ourselves in the performance of that Office for the benefit of the worshippers in our Parish Church. It had to be approved by the Parish Church Council and the Vicar. The Vicar considered it carefully, so did the PCC. At the meeting we waited to hear the usual 'nod thorugh' we expected. We didn't get it.
The Vicar raised the item, listened to the comments from members (all in favour) and then said quietly: "Jesus only made two rules for membership of his church. There are fifty three to be a server in this Parish if we approve this."
Our constitution did not receive approval, but we continued to Serve at the altar, and some of those at that meeting are still serving. Every time I look through the several books of Canon Law governing the Church of England I am reminded of that Constitution for the Guild of Servers. Yes, as humans we do need some 'rules' to govern ourselves, but there are times when we become so bound up in them we do well to step outside the 'rules' and tear up those that prevent us acting sensibly and in a Christian fashion. The 'Laws' laid down and made by the General Synod have, for quite some time, actually prevented us from behaving like the Christians we are supposed to be in a very wide range of matters. It is time the Church stopped being so legalistic and asked itself seriously the question; "What would Jesus do or say in this position?"
I suspect he would tell us, as he told the Pharisees, that the slavish adherence to a set of 'laws,' no matter how well intentioned, do not a good Christian make. Excluding people because they are different, labeling others because we do not like their lifestyle, or digging our heels in and taking refuge behind barriers because we don't want to have to face changing understandings or changing perceptions is not behaving in a Christian manner.
If nothing else, this debate may just provoke a revision of the Canons and perhaps a good hard look at what we are doing with the message of the gospels.
To me, that is a part of the problem. Canon Law, like any other "law" is man-made. I accept that it is made in order to regulate and maintain certain principles and behaviours, but it is not immutable and it was certainly not God-given. Like any other "law," Canon Law can be revised, reviewed, amended or even repealed. The problem with the Church of England at present, is that the General Synod has forgotten this. A large part of it wants to make more Canon Law and certainly do not want to allow any part of it to be reviewed, revised or changed.
Some years ago I was part of a group setting up a Server's Guild. One of our number, a lawyer, drafted a constitution for it. It was a masterpiece, it set out clearly what we were, what our aims were and how we regulated ourselves in the performance of that Office for the benefit of the worshippers in our Parish Church. It had to be approved by the Parish Church Council and the Vicar. The Vicar considered it carefully, so did the PCC. At the meeting we waited to hear the usual 'nod thorugh' we expected. We didn't get it.
The Vicar raised the item, listened to the comments from members (all in favour) and then said quietly: "Jesus only made two rules for membership of his church. There are fifty three to be a server in this Parish if we approve this."
Our constitution did not receive approval, but we continued to Serve at the altar, and some of those at that meeting are still serving. Every time I look through the several books of Canon Law governing the Church of England I am reminded of that Constitution for the Guild of Servers. Yes, as humans we do need some 'rules' to govern ourselves, but there are times when we become so bound up in them we do well to step outside the 'rules' and tear up those that prevent us acting sensibly and in a Christian fashion. The 'Laws' laid down and made by the General Synod have, for quite some time, actually prevented us from behaving like the Christians we are supposed to be in a very wide range of matters. It is time the Church stopped being so legalistic and asked itself seriously the question; "What would Jesus do or say in this position?"
I suspect he would tell us, as he told the Pharisees, that the slavish adherence to a set of 'laws,' no matter how well intentioned, do not a good Christian make. Excluding people because they are different, labeling others because we do not like their lifestyle, or digging our heels in and taking refuge behind barriers because we don't want to have to face changing understandings or changing perceptions is not behaving in a Christian manner.
If nothing else, this debate may just provoke a revision of the Canons and perhaps a good hard look at what we are doing with the message of the gospels.
Thursday, 14 June 2012
The Great Marriage Debate - Again
It seems I'm not the only one uncomfortable with some of the utterances by sections of the CofE on the proposed changes to the marriage law. At least one Bishop is as well. In a brilliant post, far more erudite than my own, Bishop Tim Ellis, Suffragan Bishop of Grantham in the Diocese of Lincoln has written in his Blog a piece entitled "Not in my name." I confess I have to agree with every word he says. The debate has been hijacked by those with extreme views at both ends of the spectrum. As the Bishop says, the whole is being driven by minorities, including some ecclesiastical elites, some fundamentalist laity and the vast majority are either not making their voices heard or being allowed to express a view for themselves.
This is further borne out by another blog post - this time a Lay person. Another Reader, John McLuckie has expressed his thoughts on the matter in a post entitled "Dear Church of England." Again, he makes a number of excellent points, but he sums it up very well when he says -
This is further borne out by another blog post - this time a Lay person. Another Reader, John McLuckie has expressed his thoughts on the matter in a post entitled "Dear Church of England." Again, he makes a number of excellent points, but he sums it up very well when he says -
But my deepest concern is to do with the behaviour of the church as a Christian body. I became an Anglican in part because I was attracted to a way of doing theology that was open to human experience. It seems that I was mistaken. When the Church of England consistently favours scripture and tradition over reason, it devalues humanity.Indeed. This is my concern as well. In refusing to recognise the human needs and the humanity of those who are different in their lifestyle, not, as some claim through choice, the church effectively devalues them as people. If we allow this vociferous group to continue to drive the church's thinking and agenda, we risk allowing them to paint us, not just into a corner, but out of the 'picture' altogether.
Wednesday, 13 June 2012
The Great Marriage Debate
I'll come straight out and admit that I regard the near hysteria of certain sections of the Church of England over the proposal to call the union between two people a "marriage" regardless of their sex, a little less than truly Christian. It is predicated on the doctrine of the Church which describes "marriage" as being between a man and a woman for the purposes of procreation. It also draws on the Bible (KJV canon) and one frequently hears a quote of one of the three texts which are generally interpreted as injunctions against same sex relationships. Interestingly, in the Vulgate Canon of books and translations, the number of texts is down to two and a maybe ... But, the context is very important when reading these in any version.
Most Christian professions argue that the Bible requires us to "love the sinner; loathe the sin." In the case of homosexuality, this means loving the "Gay" and loathing the sexual act. It is a very tricky balancing act, because it can easily become a weapon against any person who admits being in a "relationship." Much of this is also driven by the interpretation of the "sin" of Sodom and Gomorrah as being sexual, whereas it is actually their breaking of the sacred rules of hospitality to the stranger that is the cause of their downfall. Likewise, the "sin" of Onan is not the act he commits to avoid making the woman pregnant, but the fact that he is defying God by NOT making her pregnant.
First of all, the present concept of "marriage" is of fairly recent date. Yes, there is a "marriage rite" in the earliest CofE Prayer Books, just as there was in the Roman Catholic missals. But this doesn't necessarily mean everyone went through that process. Many didn't. As recently as the 19th Century many couples simply "cohabited" as the process involved in getting "married" could be extremely protracted, expensive and fraught with difficulty. In the early 19th Century, in parts of Britain, "fairs" were still being held where a farmer or farm labourer could bring along his "wife" and trade her for another. According to one source I have read it was really only from the 14th Century onwards that the "common" people began to ask the church for a formal "blessing" of their marriages. This was driven, in part, by a desire to mark such a union in the same manner as their overlords.
The Church has always had a view on marriage, but in early Roman times it was the Civil Law that governed this. Marriage was an contract between families. For the commoner, it was a much less formal affair.
In most of Europe we have a system where anyone wishing to get married MUST undergo a "civil" ceremony and may then have a church ceremony. Most have also, sensibly, termed the civil side a "civil partnership" or, where it is still a marriage, have a "civil partnership" ceremony for those of the same sex. It is a purely legal matter necessitated by the laws of inheritance which dictate who inherits what and when. Unlike Britain, where I could leave my entire estate to a home for disabled bats, in Germany that would not be considered a valid bequest unless my "heirs" - in the first instance my wife and in the second my children - waived their right to inherit. It is the law regarding "inheritance" which is bedevilling this debate in the UK. However, there are a number of other small problems with any change to the legal definition.
The first is that the CofE Vicar, in his legal position as "Priest of the Parish" is usually also a Marriage Officer. This means that marriage in a Church of England Parish is recognised as legally binding. If one marries in a Non-Conformist Church where the Minister is not a Marriage Officer, one would then have to undergo a Civil Marriage with a Registrar of Marriages for it to be legal and binding. Changing the law to make the CofE Vicars "marry" same sex partners creates a difficulty for the whole Church in that it is completely contrary to the Churches teaching regarding the purpose and nature of "marriage." This does create a moral dilemma for the Vicar. If he follows the teachings of the CofE, he must actually defy them to perform the ceremony. The Table of Kindred and Affinity isn't much help here either, since those who drafted it never envisaged a union between two members of the same sex.
The second problem arises in law, certainly in England. In case law, a marriage is not a marriage unless it is "consumated." That means the couple must more than cohabit, they must actually engage in a sexual act. Here again, the law is rather specific as it describes that as an act intended to procreate. Patently that can't happen between people of the same sex.
As I see it the Church has a problem. As the "Established" Church, it is required to "minister" to every member of the Parish. That also means that everyone wishing to be baptised, married or buried has the right to have this provided in their Parish Church. No, the State does not provide any funding to support this or a wide range of other things the parishioners are entitled to. Yes, we can acknowledge that the Bible does have passages suggesting that sex between two people of the same sex is not acceptable, but it was written in a climate where sexual acts between men, between women, between men and animals and all the panoply of possible sexual activity was the norm in the whole variety of fertility gods and goddesses worshipped in societies throughout the Middle East. It is also based on the idea that homosexual preferences are a "life choice" made deliberately by the individual.
The matter of "choice" is an increasingly untenable position. The growing body of scientific evidence which indicates that around 3% of all males are homosexual and around another 5% may well "swing both ways" from birth is difficult to ignore. If the Church truly believes what it teaches regarding God having made each of us as we are, then it cannot continue to deny the evidence that some of humanity simply isn't "wired" toward procreation and cannot be denied the essential human need of partnership and the grace of bonding with a kindred spirit. Yes, this is a minefield, but we do also need to ask ourselves what Christ would say and do if confronted (as he probably was) by this question.
I rather suspect his answer would put the Synod into something of an apoplectic fit, because I don't believe he would endorse their stance! That said, I do believe that Mr Cameron-Clegg has taken an unnecessarily confrontational path on this. I suspect there is a rather nasty political motive behind it, since the solution is a simple one - just redesignate "marriage" as a "civil partnership." Those who wish to can continue to be "married" and the non-believers who wish to can call it what they like. Since the whole is a civil law matter anyway why challenge the faith of those who find the change spiritually difficult? It achieves nothing except to create deep and bitter division over the "right" of a few hundred activists to force their domestic arrangements into the public eye.
What this is most likely to achieve is the mass resignation of Church of England vicars and clergy as Marriage Officers. That will cause enormous hardship for thousands.
Most Christian professions argue that the Bible requires us to "love the sinner; loathe the sin." In the case of homosexuality, this means loving the "Gay" and loathing the sexual act. It is a very tricky balancing act, because it can easily become a weapon against any person who admits being in a "relationship." Much of this is also driven by the interpretation of the "sin" of Sodom and Gomorrah as being sexual, whereas it is actually their breaking of the sacred rules of hospitality to the stranger that is the cause of their downfall. Likewise, the "sin" of Onan is not the act he commits to avoid making the woman pregnant, but the fact that he is defying God by NOT making her pregnant.
First of all, the present concept of "marriage" is of fairly recent date. Yes, there is a "marriage rite" in the earliest CofE Prayer Books, just as there was in the Roman Catholic missals. But this doesn't necessarily mean everyone went through that process. Many didn't. As recently as the 19th Century many couples simply "cohabited" as the process involved in getting "married" could be extremely protracted, expensive and fraught with difficulty. In the early 19th Century, in parts of Britain, "fairs" were still being held where a farmer or farm labourer could bring along his "wife" and trade her for another. According to one source I have read it was really only from the 14th Century onwards that the "common" people began to ask the church for a formal "blessing" of their marriages. This was driven, in part, by a desire to mark such a union in the same manner as their overlords.
The Church has always had a view on marriage, but in early Roman times it was the Civil Law that governed this. Marriage was an contract between families. For the commoner, it was a much less formal affair.
In most of Europe we have a system where anyone wishing to get married MUST undergo a "civil" ceremony and may then have a church ceremony. Most have also, sensibly, termed the civil side a "civil partnership" or, where it is still a marriage, have a "civil partnership" ceremony for those of the same sex. It is a purely legal matter necessitated by the laws of inheritance which dictate who inherits what and when. Unlike Britain, where I could leave my entire estate to a home for disabled bats, in Germany that would not be considered a valid bequest unless my "heirs" - in the first instance my wife and in the second my children - waived their right to inherit. It is the law regarding "inheritance" which is bedevilling this debate in the UK. However, there are a number of other small problems with any change to the legal definition.
The first is that the CofE Vicar, in his legal position as "Priest of the Parish" is usually also a Marriage Officer. This means that marriage in a Church of England Parish is recognised as legally binding. If one marries in a Non-Conformist Church where the Minister is not a Marriage Officer, one would then have to undergo a Civil Marriage with a Registrar of Marriages for it to be legal and binding. Changing the law to make the CofE Vicars "marry" same sex partners creates a difficulty for the whole Church in that it is completely contrary to the Churches teaching regarding the purpose and nature of "marriage." This does create a moral dilemma for the Vicar. If he follows the teachings of the CofE, he must actually defy them to perform the ceremony. The Table of Kindred and Affinity isn't much help here either, since those who drafted it never envisaged a union between two members of the same sex.
The second problem arises in law, certainly in England. In case law, a marriage is not a marriage unless it is "consumated." That means the couple must more than cohabit, they must actually engage in a sexual act. Here again, the law is rather specific as it describes that as an act intended to procreate. Patently that can't happen between people of the same sex.
As I see it the Church has a problem. As the "Established" Church, it is required to "minister" to every member of the Parish. That also means that everyone wishing to be baptised, married or buried has the right to have this provided in their Parish Church. No, the State does not provide any funding to support this or a wide range of other things the parishioners are entitled to. Yes, we can acknowledge that the Bible does have passages suggesting that sex between two people of the same sex is not acceptable, but it was written in a climate where sexual acts between men, between women, between men and animals and all the panoply of possible sexual activity was the norm in the whole variety of fertility gods and goddesses worshipped in societies throughout the Middle East. It is also based on the idea that homosexual preferences are a "life choice" made deliberately by the individual.
The matter of "choice" is an increasingly untenable position. The growing body of scientific evidence which indicates that around 3% of all males are homosexual and around another 5% may well "swing both ways" from birth is difficult to ignore. If the Church truly believes what it teaches regarding God having made each of us as we are, then it cannot continue to deny the evidence that some of humanity simply isn't "wired" toward procreation and cannot be denied the essential human need of partnership and the grace of bonding with a kindred spirit. Yes, this is a minefield, but we do also need to ask ourselves what Christ would say and do if confronted (as he probably was) by this question.
I rather suspect his answer would put the Synod into something of an apoplectic fit, because I don't believe he would endorse their stance! That said, I do believe that Mr Cameron-Clegg has taken an unnecessarily confrontational path on this. I suspect there is a rather nasty political motive behind it, since the solution is a simple one - just redesignate "marriage" as a "civil partnership." Those who wish to can continue to be "married" and the non-believers who wish to can call it what they like. Since the whole is a civil law matter anyway why challenge the faith of those who find the change spiritually difficult? It achieves nothing except to create deep and bitter division over the "right" of a few hundred activists to force their domestic arrangements into the public eye.
What this is most likely to achieve is the mass resignation of Church of England vicars and clergy as Marriage Officers. That will cause enormous hardship for thousands.
Tuesday, 12 June 2012
Saving civilisation
I was reminded today that it is now popularly believed that all the work of the Ancient Greek philosophers and scientists - if not all the 'civilised' knowledge of the west, would have been 'lost' if the Muslim invaders from Arabia had not preserved it. While it is certainly true that they carried it back into Spain and copiously copied every document they found in each of the major centres they overran between 800 and 1300 AD, it is false to claim that these documents had been 'lost' in the west.
In a fascinating book entitled "How the Irish saved civilisation," one is reminded, of the explosion in Irish literacy following Christianisation of that land between 429 and 500 AD. The Irish discovered writing, better, they discovered reading, copying and recording. Everything they got their hands on, they copied. And they shared it. We are often told how the Abbot of the Notre Dame community had a 'library' of only 16 books while the Caliph of Cordoba had hundreds, but what is ignored is how documents copied by the Irish were populating monastic libraries all over Northern Europe at this time. I was surprised to learn that one of the oldest extant copies of a work by Aristotle came from an Irish monastery and fetched up in a University collection in Germany.
Much is also made these days of the destruction, by one of the more ignorant 'Christian' governors of Egypt, of the library of Alexandria. What is forgotten though is that much of its content was shared between all the other great libraries, in Rome, Byzantium, Damascus and elsewhere. Nor was this 'Christian' the only destroyer of such libraries. A later Muslim governor would do it again, more thoroughly. We can only be thankful, I suppose, that copiests had already copied and distributed almost everything it contained.
We should not ignore the fact that the libraries of Byzantium contained all these works and much, much more. They were 'lost' the Christendom when the Arabic invaders finally conquered the city in 1453. But 'lost' is perhaps the wrong word. Many of the intellectuals who had found a home there fled to Italy, Austria, Romania, Hungary and other western lands - taking a great deal of the library content with them. Copies of these 'lost' documents have turned up in some rather remote places - like Poland and Russia.
It is popular to claim that "Christianity believed the world was flat" and "Islam taught it was a globe." Peasants in western Europe might have believed in a flat earth, seamen certainly didn't and neither did Christian intellectuals and monastics. They'd read Ptolemy's treatise on astronomy - or at least heard of it. Likewise the claims that "Christian doctrine dictated that the Earth was centre of the Universe, based on the Bible" are false. Christian teaching was based on Aristotle and Plato - until Copernicus (Polish monastic and priest) worked out that we moved around the sun. He, realising the implications, didn't make a big fuss about it - that fell to Galileo who had to "make a point" to prove his genius. In part this mythology is the product of both anti-Roman Catholic propaganda generated by the more rabid anti-catholics and the later Victorian "scientific" community's desire to take science out of the "Arts" in the universities.
I have always found it fascinating that this major conquest occured at a moment in time when Islam was already turning against intellectualism and in retreat elsewhere. Spanish Al-Andalus was less than 40 years from its demise (Granada surrendered in 1492 to the Spanish king) and the sacking of Baghdad by the Mongols in 1326 had led to the death of the last Caliph in the Middle East (They claimed direct descent from the family of the Prophet) and a rising tide of fundamentalist thinking. This seems to be forgotten by many of the promoters of the idea that Islam is the preserver of science and peace and Christianity the retarder to progress.
The Mongol conquest in 1326 traumatised Islam, turning it inward, but also making it more fundamentalist and martial in nature. The Ottomans didn't rest on their laurels after conquering Byzantium, they almost succeeded in subjugating Europe via the back door of the Balkans, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary and Austria. It was a long and bloody campaign, but it was turned back. The legacy, however, continues to this day. Almost all the problems in the Balkans can be traced to the attempt to forcibly impose Islam on the conquered lands. Nor does it end there, much of the fundamentalist nature of the more extreme forms of Islam which have emerged in the last sixty years also have their origins in the reverses suffered between 1326 and 1600.
Its a fascinating study, but, unfortunately, not a popular one with our current politically correct educationists and anti-religious propagandists.
In a fascinating book entitled "How the Irish saved civilisation," one is reminded, of the explosion in Irish literacy following Christianisation of that land between 429 and 500 AD. The Irish discovered writing, better, they discovered reading, copying and recording. Everything they got their hands on, they copied. And they shared it. We are often told how the Abbot of the Notre Dame community had a 'library' of only 16 books while the Caliph of Cordoba had hundreds, but what is ignored is how documents copied by the Irish were populating monastic libraries all over Northern Europe at this time. I was surprised to learn that one of the oldest extant copies of a work by Aristotle came from an Irish monastery and fetched up in a University collection in Germany.
Much is also made these days of the destruction, by one of the more ignorant 'Christian' governors of Egypt, of the library of Alexandria. What is forgotten though is that much of its content was shared between all the other great libraries, in Rome, Byzantium, Damascus and elsewhere. Nor was this 'Christian' the only destroyer of such libraries. A later Muslim governor would do it again, more thoroughly. We can only be thankful, I suppose, that copiests had already copied and distributed almost everything it contained.
We should not ignore the fact that the libraries of Byzantium contained all these works and much, much more. They were 'lost' the Christendom when the Arabic invaders finally conquered the city in 1453. But 'lost' is perhaps the wrong word. Many of the intellectuals who had found a home there fled to Italy, Austria, Romania, Hungary and other western lands - taking a great deal of the library content with them. Copies of these 'lost' documents have turned up in some rather remote places - like Poland and Russia.
It is popular to claim that "Christianity believed the world was flat" and "Islam taught it was a globe." Peasants in western Europe might have believed in a flat earth, seamen certainly didn't and neither did Christian intellectuals and monastics. They'd read Ptolemy's treatise on astronomy - or at least heard of it. Likewise the claims that "Christian doctrine dictated that the Earth was centre of the Universe, based on the Bible" are false. Christian teaching was based on Aristotle and Plato - until Copernicus (Polish monastic and priest) worked out that we moved around the sun. He, realising the implications, didn't make a big fuss about it - that fell to Galileo who had to "make a point" to prove his genius. In part this mythology is the product of both anti-Roman Catholic propaganda generated by the more rabid anti-catholics and the later Victorian "scientific" community's desire to take science out of the "Arts" in the universities.
I have always found it fascinating that this major conquest occured at a moment in time when Islam was already turning against intellectualism and in retreat elsewhere. Spanish Al-Andalus was less than 40 years from its demise (Granada surrendered in 1492 to the Spanish king) and the sacking of Baghdad by the Mongols in 1326 had led to the death of the last Caliph in the Middle East (They claimed direct descent from the family of the Prophet) and a rising tide of fundamentalist thinking. This seems to be forgotten by many of the promoters of the idea that Islam is the preserver of science and peace and Christianity the retarder to progress.
The Mongol conquest in 1326 traumatised Islam, turning it inward, but also making it more fundamentalist and martial in nature. The Ottomans didn't rest on their laurels after conquering Byzantium, they almost succeeded in subjugating Europe via the back door of the Balkans, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary and Austria. It was a long and bloody campaign, but it was turned back. The legacy, however, continues to this day. Almost all the problems in the Balkans can be traced to the attempt to forcibly impose Islam on the conquered lands. Nor does it end there, much of the fundamentalist nature of the more extreme forms of Islam which have emerged in the last sixty years also have their origins in the reverses suffered between 1326 and 1600.
Its a fascinating study, but, unfortunately, not a popular one with our current politically correct educationists and anti-religious propagandists.
Monday, 11 June 2012
A Good Question
I note with interest that the pundits in the UK and in the US are still promoting the idea that "The End of the €uro Is Nigh!" I wonder what they hope to achieve by this to be honest, because that is exactly what they are not being. There certainly are problems within the €urozone, but the austerity measures adopted (imposed according to some) are stabilising most of them. Greece remains a major problem, mainl because the Greek government still hasn't addressed the issue of non-payment/collection of taxes. Spain has a major problem at present, but, with the help of the EZB, it now has some funds to get it going again.
On our recent stay in Denmark it was pointed out to us that a majority of Danes expect to join the €uro within the next few years. To them it is a matter of when, not if.
Across the €urozone the Balance of Payments is more favourable than that of either the UK or the US. Industries are recovering and the majority of governments - with the exceptions of Greece, Italy and Spain at present, are behaving sensibly and cutting their cloth to suit their pockets.
Something the Postulant reminded me of today, is the situation with regard to legislation and regulation. Ever since 1997, the UK has been regulating and legislating as if there was no tomorrow. The usual mantra from the civil service is that "The EU requires it" but that doesn't seem to be the case - at least not from the manner in which this is handled elsewhere in the EU. I am left to believe then, that the flood of regulations and legislation is Whiethall's desperate grab for ever more money from the taxpayer and even more control over the minutia of individuals lives.
I am no longer certain this assault on the UK's ancient freedoms is coming from the EU. Frankly I think it is generated more by the incompetence of the politicians compounded by the ambitions of the Civil Servants. Sooner rather than later, someone will have to give these folks a reality check. Probably at the point of a hayfork.
As for those trying to talk the €uro into oblivion, I rather think their reality check will come sooner than Whitehall's. I suspect that before much longer the €uro will start to strengthen - and when it does it will prove the doomsayers wrong. Of course, at present, it suits me to have the £ Sterling stronger than the €uro. My pension is paid in Sterling ...
On our recent stay in Denmark it was pointed out to us that a majority of Danes expect to join the €uro within the next few years. To them it is a matter of when, not if.
Across the €urozone the Balance of Payments is more favourable than that of either the UK or the US. Industries are recovering and the majority of governments - with the exceptions of Greece, Italy and Spain at present, are behaving sensibly and cutting their cloth to suit their pockets.
Something the Postulant reminded me of today, is the situation with regard to legislation and regulation. Ever since 1997, the UK has been regulating and legislating as if there was no tomorrow. The usual mantra from the civil service is that "The EU requires it" but that doesn't seem to be the case - at least not from the manner in which this is handled elsewhere in the EU. I am left to believe then, that the flood of regulations and legislation is Whiethall's desperate grab for ever more money from the taxpayer and even more control over the minutia of individuals lives.
I am no longer certain this assault on the UK's ancient freedoms is coming from the EU. Frankly I think it is generated more by the incompetence of the politicians compounded by the ambitions of the Civil Servants. Sooner rather than later, someone will have to give these folks a reality check. Probably at the point of a hayfork.
As for those trying to talk the €uro into oblivion, I rather think their reality check will come sooner than Whitehall's. I suspect that before much longer the €uro will start to strengthen - and when it does it will prove the doomsayers wrong. Of course, at present, it suits me to have the £ Sterling stronger than the €uro. My pension is paid in Sterling ...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)