In studying my father and grandfathers' histories I may have stumbled on something which explains a lot about my childhood relationships with all three and may, in fact, suggest a line of research into the diverse responses in many western societies of the post-War generations. If someone reading this would like to give me loads of research funding and some research assistants, I'm sure I could develop a credible doctoral thesis on this theme.
Looking back at my father's problems health-wise, in relationships and in his dealings with people generally, I realised that quite a lot of these were directly related to his own childhood and then compounded by his experiences in World War 2 - three years of which were spent fighting the Japanese in Burma, the East Indies and the Indian Ocean. He saw all manner of horrors, starting right at the outset in his basic training when HMS Hecla, a submarine 'mother' ship, arrived in Simonstown after being mined. The Trainees, many of them barely 18, were sent into the flooded compartments to retrieve the bodies that had been in them for almost ten days.
Posted to the battleship HMS Barham, the experience on HMS Hecla was to be repeated when the battleship was torpedoed at Diego Saurez by a Japanese mini-sub and one of Barham's main magazines caught fire and had to be flooded to save the ship. As she was 'closed up' to action stations at the time, the magazine was manned. The men in it drowned or were burned or both. It was two weeks before the ship could be brought into the floating dock in Durban and, once again, the junior rates got the job ...
My maternal grandfather had a very bad time in WW1, having run away from home to join up aged 15 (his father was Colour Sergeant of the Royal Irish Rifles), he was nearly killed on the first day of the Somme. He survived three days in a shell hole only because his wounds had become infested with maggots. When he and his lifelong best friend were eventually retrieved - having been found by chance by a burial party - they were not considered likely to survive and so did not lose any limbs, which the wounds they had would normally have been treated by amputation. They survived that to be judged 'unfit' for the infantry, but 'fit' to become Gunners. The slaughter of "Flander's Fields," followed by the Irish Civil War, left a deep and lasting mark on "Ada's" psyche, which impacted on his relationship with his daughter (my mother) and later on my brother and I.
The little I know of my paternal grandfather's history suggests that he also suffered a traumatic childhood. His father, an Army officer, was killed in Barbeton when grandfather was barely four years old. His mother's relatives descended on her and their farm like vultures and she, his sisters and himself endured a very difficult time thereafter. His relationship with his children is probably best described as volatile, his childhood compounded by the Anglo-Boer War and his service with one of the regiments sent out to deal with it, certainly didn't sit well with him either.
Based on my own relationships, and knowing my own reaction to many things as a result, I find myself convinced that their experiences have coloured my view of a wide range of matters, from politics, to war, to relationships. It is a matter of fact that I suffer from a degree of insecurity in myself, lack confidence in a number of areas and was a'late developer.' Some of this I have, by sheer 'bloody-mindedness' and at some cost to myself and some of those closest to me, been able to compensate for if not overcome. I know I'm not alone at this, and a great deal I've read recently about the experiences of some of my contemporaries and some of the children of men who fought in the US Forces in Korea, Vietnam and Cambodia, suggests that many of the social problems and inabilities among many younger folk today to accept discipline, or to accept a different point of view to their own, stem from the traumas their fathers suffered and the damage this did to the relationship with their children.
As I said at the outset, I think there's at least one PhD in this study, possibly several. Now, if someone wants to put up the money, I know several people who'd be interested ...
Monday, 11 February 2013
In Memoriam
Today my mother would have been 87. Sadly she died in 1999 of complications following surgery for a blockage of the small intestine. She was not the easiest person in the world to get along with, having a fiery temper and a very strong will, but she was fiercely protective of my brother and I and did her best to raise us in what she considered to be a proper manner. She did not have an easy life, her marriage was difficult from the start, but she once told us that my father was the only man she'd ever truly loved.
It's a shame that it could not have been what she hoped it would be.
It's a shame that it could not have been what she hoped it would be.
May they both Rest in Peace.
I think they've earned it.
Friday, 8 February 2013
Tax Avoidance Hurts Us All
I read this article entitled "The Economic Case Against Tax Dodging" on the blog Another Angry Voice, with great interest and agree with almost everything the author says. Almost everything. The one thing I disagree with is the suggestion that Central Government can provide anything other than a very narrow range of services such as police, fire and emergency service, health care (with qualification) and defence/security, efficiently. Whitehall is the classic case of a bloated and inefficient bureaucracy, with duplication of activity one of the most rampant causes for the inability to actually deliver anything on budget or within reasonable timescales.
They are the very people responsible for the award of mega million pound contracts to companies that are at the very spearhead of the list of "tax avoiders" which, as the author of the article I've linked to above identifes, costs the UK taxman £120 billion a year. Not only are they avoiding contributing to the National Economy and government, but they are then robbing the taxpayer blind to provide services the Civil Service is contracting out to them while still retaining all the staff they employ to provide the service they no longer provide.
There are two problems here. The tax avoidance by the mega-multi-nationals is one, the incompetence of Whitehall and its refusal to cut out the duplications, the conflicts and the empire building that bloats every Department of State is the other. Even if we could collect half the avoided tax, and reduce Whitehall's bloated budgets by as little as 10% (I know they calim they are doing this - but the real numbers give them the lie) we could get the country out of debt and we could get the economy going again.
Time, I think, to get tough on the tax avoiding and on the bloated Whitehall Mandarins.
They are the very people responsible for the award of mega million pound contracts to companies that are at the very spearhead of the list of "tax avoiders" which, as the author of the article I've linked to above identifes, costs the UK taxman £120 billion a year. Not only are they avoiding contributing to the National Economy and government, but they are then robbing the taxpayer blind to provide services the Civil Service is contracting out to them while still retaining all the staff they employ to provide the service they no longer provide.
There are two problems here. The tax avoidance by the mega-multi-nationals is one, the incompetence of Whitehall and its refusal to cut out the duplications, the conflicts and the empire building that bloats every Department of State is the other. Even if we could collect half the avoided tax, and reduce Whitehall's bloated budgets by as little as 10% (I know they calim they are doing this - but the real numbers give them the lie) we could get the country out of debt and we could get the economy going again.
Time, I think, to get tough on the tax avoiding and on the bloated Whitehall Mandarins.
Thursday, 7 February 2013
That Wealth Gap ...
We are frequently told that the gap between the "rich" and the "poor" in the UK is widening and becoming a chasm - usually by some extremely well paid and well funded 'researcher' working for one or other of the Left-wing "think Tanks." There is certainly some evidence that the gap between those at the very top of the tree and those at the bottom is getting wider, but this is perhaps a misleading picture, since, at least in western nations, the bulk of the populace do not live in "poverty." The actual spread of "wealth" is quite broad, and the majority of our populace actually live quite well.
The same cannot be said for many other nations, where the gap between "rich" and "poor" is a chasm - with very few "bridges" over which someone from the "poor" end of the scale can get a better share of the wealth. From the online magazine, Financial Management, I learned that the UK, US, Europe and Canada are actually not the worst places even though this is what the propagandists of the Left love to project. To my surprise I learned from their graphic, that South Africa is now one of the worst, with India, China, Argentina, Chile, the Philippines, Brazil, Namibia, Bolivia and several others - interestingly some of the former Communist territories - have much less 'distribution' of the wealth of the nation.
Certainly in the 'developed' nations one of the critical factors that causes this divergence is the penchant of the employers and negotiators of pay rises, to award 'across the board' pay adjustments on a 'percentage' basis. As any school child can tell you (assuming they've actually learned it in today's rather odd way of teaching maths) that 5% of £100 is a lot less than 5% of £10,000. So, the guy on £10,000 is going to get an extra £500 and the guy on the bottom gets just £5. If this is allowed to continue indefinitely, eventually the guy on the top end is earning a disproportionate salary by comparison to the guy at the bottom. However, convincing the middle and top earners to accept an fixed amount across the board is going to take some doing! The fact is that, if everyone got the same amount in their pay rise, the current steep incline between top and bottom would stabilise and the gap would close slowly.
However, the developing world there is another facet to this problem. In recent years we have heard a great deal about how "The 1%" deprive the rest of the populace, but the fact is that the west, roughy 10% of the current world population, are far better off and share a far better distribution of wealth, than the other 90%. Perhaps the most important reason for that is the absence, in most societies outside of what we call the "western democracies" of a large group of "Middle Income Earners." Perhaps this also accounts for the massive corruption in most of those countries where 'favours' are required in order to get some official to do what they are (under)paid to do.
Looking at some of the really slewed imbalances identified by the Financial Management graphic, there is a suggestion that some of the massive wealth discrepancy could be related to the siphoning off of "aid" funds as some are among the poorest nations on Earth. Having visited some of them, I can attest to having seen, cheek by jowl, opulence on an unimaginable scale and hovels with nothing of the modern conveniences and only the minimum of food to eat.
I think, next time we complain about the "Wealth Gap" or see a report of it and about how badly we, in the west, are faring, let's spare a thought for those who live in countries where the distribution of wealth is far, far worse. Yes, we do have people living on incomes below the so-called 'bread line,' but we also have many, many more who live very comfortably, and even our poorest are able to get help which is unimaginable to anyone living in India, the Philippines, or any one of many states in Africa.
Once again, it is a question of keeping things in perspective. Something our politicians and media don't seem to be very good at ...
The same cannot be said for many other nations, where the gap between "rich" and "poor" is a chasm - with very few "bridges" over which someone from the "poor" end of the scale can get a better share of the wealth. From the online magazine, Financial Management, I learned that the UK, US, Europe and Canada are actually not the worst places even though this is what the propagandists of the Left love to project. To my surprise I learned from their graphic, that South Africa is now one of the worst, with India, China, Argentina, Chile, the Philippines, Brazil, Namibia, Bolivia and several others - interestingly some of the former Communist territories - have much less 'distribution' of the wealth of the nation.
Certainly in the 'developed' nations one of the critical factors that causes this divergence is the penchant of the employers and negotiators of pay rises, to award 'across the board' pay adjustments on a 'percentage' basis. As any school child can tell you (assuming they've actually learned it in today's rather odd way of teaching maths) that 5% of £100 is a lot less than 5% of £10,000. So, the guy on £10,000 is going to get an extra £500 and the guy on the bottom gets just £5. If this is allowed to continue indefinitely, eventually the guy on the top end is earning a disproportionate salary by comparison to the guy at the bottom. However, convincing the middle and top earners to accept an fixed amount across the board is going to take some doing! The fact is that, if everyone got the same amount in their pay rise, the current steep incline between top and bottom would stabilise and the gap would close slowly.
However, the developing world there is another facet to this problem. In recent years we have heard a great deal about how "The 1%" deprive the rest of the populace, but the fact is that the west, roughy 10% of the current world population, are far better off and share a far better distribution of wealth, than the other 90%. Perhaps the most important reason for that is the absence, in most societies outside of what we call the "western democracies" of a large group of "Middle Income Earners." Perhaps this also accounts for the massive corruption in most of those countries where 'favours' are required in order to get some official to do what they are (under)paid to do.
Looking at some of the really slewed imbalances identified by the Financial Management graphic, there is a suggestion that some of the massive wealth discrepancy could be related to the siphoning off of "aid" funds as some are among the poorest nations on Earth. Having visited some of them, I can attest to having seen, cheek by jowl, opulence on an unimaginable scale and hovels with nothing of the modern conveniences and only the minimum of food to eat.
I think, next time we complain about the "Wealth Gap" or see a report of it and about how badly we, in the west, are faring, let's spare a thought for those who live in countries where the distribution of wealth is far, far worse. Yes, we do have people living on incomes below the so-called 'bread line,' but we also have many, many more who live very comfortably, and even our poorest are able to get help which is unimaginable to anyone living in India, the Philippines, or any one of many states in Africa.
Once again, it is a question of keeping things in perspective. Something our politicians and media don't seem to be very good at ...
Wednesday, 6 February 2013
Argentinian Dreams ...
I see the Argentine Foreign Minister is in London, and whining about the "Malvinas" again. Funny how this rears its head everytime they manage to crash their economy. I suppose it makes a convenient distraction for their population. Its an old ploy, focus people on an 'external enemy' and distract them from the morons ruining the country from within.
The Argentinian government claims the people living in the Falkland Islands were all "transfered there." It is, he says, an issue of "territorial colonialism." According to this drip, 'not a single country in the world recognises Britain's colonial seizure" of the islands. It seems to have escaped his notice that the people living in the Falklands are, after 180 years now fifth generation "natives" of the islands which were uninhabited when their forebears settled there. If the islands "belong" to anyone it is the people who live there, not a bunch of political pygmies in Buenos Aires or London. Nor is it any business of that utterly worthless organisation based in New York which seems to exist to promote the interests of dictators and propagandists for some of the world's worst terror organisations such as Hamas and Hezbollah. It is no business of anyone but the Falkland Islanders, only their opinion counts - and they are adamant they wish to remain British.
Whether Buenos Aires 'recognises' the outcome of the referendum the Islanders are holding or not is immaterial. Not least because more recent research shows that the Argentinian cliams are bogus anyway. If anyone has a "territorial" claim, it is Uruguay, not the territorially ambitious Argentinians. However, given that the Islanders have been there for 180 years, I'd say the matter is settled. The islands are theirs. Handing them to a neighbouring state simply because of mythical "history" and geography opens the gates to some more interesting land transfers for the future.
How about Mexico's much more legitimate claims to the territories now called California, New Mexico or Texas? Perhaps we should include Florida? Yes, I can certainly see the US handing those 'back' to Mexico just because the Mexicans want them. After all, they've not been "American" for as long as the Falklands have been British. If one looked closely at present world national boundaries, they've all changed significantly in the last 200 years, so what does the Argentinan whinging suggest about that? Should the Czech Republic give back the Sudeten Province to Germany? Poland hand back West Prussia? Russia give back East Prussia? Albania give back the territory it has been 'given' by the international community in the last 30 years?
None of that is going to happen, so why should the Argentinians have a special case? They don't, this must be treated for what it is, a simple case of making a grab for territory that was not theirs, is not theirs and will never be theirs. It is a distraction to divert their own people from the collapse of their economy and the civil unrest now sweeping their country.
We should not even give their whinging a hearing and we should make it clear to everyone that another little "military adventure" will meet with the same response as it did in 1982. Only the Falkland Islanders have the right to decide who rules them and who controls their islands. No one else.
The Argentinian government claims the people living in the Falkland Islands were all "transfered there." It is, he says, an issue of "territorial colonialism." According to this drip, 'not a single country in the world recognises Britain's colonial seizure" of the islands. It seems to have escaped his notice that the people living in the Falklands are, after 180 years now fifth generation "natives" of the islands which were uninhabited when their forebears settled there. If the islands "belong" to anyone it is the people who live there, not a bunch of political pygmies in Buenos Aires or London. Nor is it any business of that utterly worthless organisation based in New York which seems to exist to promote the interests of dictators and propagandists for some of the world's worst terror organisations such as Hamas and Hezbollah. It is no business of anyone but the Falkland Islanders, only their opinion counts - and they are adamant they wish to remain British.
Whether Buenos Aires 'recognises' the outcome of the referendum the Islanders are holding or not is immaterial. Not least because more recent research shows that the Argentinian cliams are bogus anyway. If anyone has a "territorial" claim, it is Uruguay, not the territorially ambitious Argentinians. However, given that the Islanders have been there for 180 years, I'd say the matter is settled. The islands are theirs. Handing them to a neighbouring state simply because of mythical "history" and geography opens the gates to some more interesting land transfers for the future.
How about Mexico's much more legitimate claims to the territories now called California, New Mexico or Texas? Perhaps we should include Florida? Yes, I can certainly see the US handing those 'back' to Mexico just because the Mexicans want them. After all, they've not been "American" for as long as the Falklands have been British. If one looked closely at present world national boundaries, they've all changed significantly in the last 200 years, so what does the Argentinan whinging suggest about that? Should the Czech Republic give back the Sudeten Province to Germany? Poland hand back West Prussia? Russia give back East Prussia? Albania give back the territory it has been 'given' by the international community in the last 30 years?
None of that is going to happen, so why should the Argentinians have a special case? They don't, this must be treated for what it is, a simple case of making a grab for territory that was not theirs, is not theirs and will never be theirs. It is a distraction to divert their own people from the collapse of their economy and the civil unrest now sweeping their country.
We should not even give their whinging a hearing and we should make it clear to everyone that another little "military adventure" will meet with the same response as it did in 1982. Only the Falkland Islanders have the right to decide who rules them and who controls their islands. No one else.
Monday, 4 February 2013
A question of perspective again?
I came across some very interesting numbers recently on violent crime in the US and the UK. According to the FBI statistics the US police and Federal criminal agencies recorded 1.2 million "violent crimes" which includes all murders, assaults involving violence and weapons and physical assaults, in 2012. With a population of 314 million, this means there were 380 violent crimes for every 100,000 people in the population. By contrast, British Police recorded 1.94 million violent crimes for the same period. As the UK population is 63 million, this means we had 3,100 "violent crimes" per 100,000 people - which is, frankly, shocking.
I suspect that the reasons for this discrepancy are much more complex than it appears, though some in the US are already pointing to the ownership of firearms as one reason their "violent crime" statistics are falling while ours are rising. I don't think it is that simple, though I do believe that our lack of a clear-cut right of "self-defence" may be a contributory factor. When a pensioner defending himself from a robber with a walking stick can be charged and convicted of "assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm" because a jury of the robber's supporters felt his response to being relieved of his wallet was "disproportionate," it should be no surprise that people are afraid to retaliate. Frankly, the UK legal system is a mess, with only the criminal element and their lawyers standing to benefit from it.
For me the biggest question is, what are we doing about reducing the violent crime rate? Patently the 'softly, softly,' regime our courts are adopting doesn't work. Patently our laws are being bent and abused by criminals, yet our politicians are afraid to adopt a harder line. We know that juries are being intimidated by supporters of the accused - but we do nothing about it. We know that "suspended sentences" are seldom imposed - a recent report actually highlights the fact that many criminals convicted of violent crimes flout their paroles, flout the threat of suspended sentences and are "given another chance" by soft touch judges.
Perhaps the US arms lobby has a point. After all, a criminal who's been shot dead during his attempted crime, doesn't repeat the offence - ever. No, I'm not an advocate of everyone having free and easy access to a firearm, but it is certainly no coincidence that, since the Blair ban on the ownership of handguns, gun crime in the UK has shot through the roof and is, no doubt, a major factor in the violent crime statistics I've quoted above ...
The question remains, what is being done about it?
I suspect that the reasons for this discrepancy are much more complex than it appears, though some in the US are already pointing to the ownership of firearms as one reason their "violent crime" statistics are falling while ours are rising. I don't think it is that simple, though I do believe that our lack of a clear-cut right of "self-defence" may be a contributory factor. When a pensioner defending himself from a robber with a walking stick can be charged and convicted of "assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm" because a jury of the robber's supporters felt his response to being relieved of his wallet was "disproportionate," it should be no surprise that people are afraid to retaliate. Frankly, the UK legal system is a mess, with only the criminal element and their lawyers standing to benefit from it.
For me the biggest question is, what are we doing about reducing the violent crime rate? Patently the 'softly, softly,' regime our courts are adopting doesn't work. Patently our laws are being bent and abused by criminals, yet our politicians are afraid to adopt a harder line. We know that juries are being intimidated by supporters of the accused - but we do nothing about it. We know that "suspended sentences" are seldom imposed - a recent report actually highlights the fact that many criminals convicted of violent crimes flout their paroles, flout the threat of suspended sentences and are "given another chance" by soft touch judges.
Perhaps the US arms lobby has a point. After all, a criminal who's been shot dead during his attempted crime, doesn't repeat the offence - ever. No, I'm not an advocate of everyone having free and easy access to a firearm, but it is certainly no coincidence that, since the Blair ban on the ownership of handguns, gun crime in the UK has shot through the roof and is, no doubt, a major factor in the violent crime statistics I've quoted above ...
The question remains, what is being done about it?
Sunday, 3 February 2013
Candlemas
Is actually the 2nd February, and is also called "The Presentation of Christ in the Temple" or "The Purification of the Virgin Mary." It seems to me to have been entirely appropraie for the Old Catholic Church I attend now to mark it with a celebration of "First Communion" for all the youngsters in our community being admitted to the Eucharist. This year it included two adults as well. It marks the start of their journey toward Confirmation, typically at around 15 to 16 in the Old Catholic tradition, and ahead of them lies an interesting few years in which they will learn a great deal about the faith the profess and for which the Eucharist and the receiving of the communion elements is central.
Harry joined us again for the service and behaved perfectly throughout, he actually seems to like the organ. As soon as it starts, he settles down to watch and listen. Today he had a treat though, since, once the service was over, we had a 'bring and share lunch' in the church and he found himself the centre of attention with all the children.
This tradition in this community, of sharing a lunch after the 'Familien Gottesdienst' once a month is a good one, as it carries forward the sense of the 'communion' being more than just the Eucharist, but a continuation of our shared life.
What is, for me, very interesting, is the number of Roman Catholics seeking a 'new' home now with the Old Catholics. It is an interesting situation as the tighter Rome tries to make their grip, the more laity and clergy find they are unable to accept it.
Harry joined us again for the service and behaved perfectly throughout, he actually seems to like the organ. As soon as it starts, he settles down to watch and listen. Today he had a treat though, since, once the service was over, we had a 'bring and share lunch' in the church and he found himself the centre of attention with all the children.
This tradition in this community, of sharing a lunch after the 'Familien Gottesdienst' once a month is a good one, as it carries forward the sense of the 'communion' being more than just the Eucharist, but a continuation of our shared life.
What is, for me, very interesting, is the number of Roman Catholics seeking a 'new' home now with the Old Catholics. It is an interesting situation as the tighter Rome tries to make their grip, the more laity and clergy find they are unable to accept it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
