Happy birthday little guy. It's been a wonderful year watching you grow and learn. May we have many more.
Wednesday, 9 October 2013
First Birthday
Harry is one year old today. He's grown into a handsome, loyal and very active lad. He's become a wonderful companion and constantly demonstrates his intelligence. He is playful, funny and very, very loving.
Happy birthday little guy. It's been a wonderful year watching you grow and learn. May we have many more.
Happy birthday little guy. It's been a wonderful year watching you grow and learn. May we have many more.
Sunday, 6 October 2013
A Little Theological Conundrum ...
Two pictures, and some ideas to bounce around the blogosphere today. We are all familiar with the various paintings of "The Last Supper", most of them done in the Renaissance or later, and almost all of them based on the literal interpretation of the Gospel accounts of the event. Jesus and the Twelve. No one else. There's even a convention in the way the twelve are arranged at the table and how they are depicted, but, and here's the conundrum, is this the right way to see it? Is this a correct depiction of the final meal Christ shared with his friends?
Those who like to keep things according to the written word would argue for a yes. However, it isn't quite so simple or straight forward. There are a number of things NOT said in the Gospel accounts for various reasons, among them the fact that the writers didn't expect anyone to be reading this who didn't "know" certain important cultural things about such a meal. Second, you didn't waste valuable papyrus writing down what they perceived to be unimportant details, so here goes the first little hand grenade.
The Gospel accounts don't tell us who else was at the table, and names only the key figures. We know, from other sources, that the "Upper Room" was in the house of the parents of John Mark, the writer of the shortest Gospel, and he actually directs his readers to other witnesses then alive who could confirm what he wrote. He wasn't one of the twelve either, at the time he was a teenager - the 'youth' who followed the twelve and Jesus to the Garden of Gethsemane wrapped only in his blanket - and ran away naked when the soldiers tried to arrest him. Why doesn't he mention the Supper was in his parents' house? He didn't need to - everyone knew.
The next bit, is equally important. This was either an Eve of Sabbath meal, or an Eve of Passover meal in a Jewish household. You cannot hold either without sharing it with the entire family, and in the second case, your neighbours and their families, the servants and the children! So, I offer MY version of the Last Supper for argument -
I post this since there is currently a huge row in many Christian churches over the role of women, usually founded on the argument "they weren't present at the Last Supper" or "they weren't selected, ordained or commissioned by Jesus". I'd suggest you read those passages again very carefully - and try to see what is not there "because you would know that".
The second picture is Medieval. It can be seen in Tewkesbury Abbey and adorns the wall of the Trinity Chapel, possibly more famous for the "Kneeling Knight" (supposedly Edward Despenser) on the roof. The painting survived the Iconoclasts largely because it was hidden from view by a wooden screen, though sadly the lower portion of it didn't survive the whitewash of the later puritan tenants. It depicts the Trinity, that stumbling block for Christians and non-Christians alike, and it shows the answer to Christ's question from the cross. Look closely at this wonderful depiction -
It depicts the figure of the Father holding the crucified Son, with the dove of the Holy Spirit between the two. The answer you seek is this - Christ's question was; Why have you forsaken me? The answer is shown here.
I have not forsaken you, I am holding you in my hands.
It depicts the offering of himself, in the form of Jesus that God the Creator and Father has made, and in the Holy Spirit continues to offer in love and grace to anyone and everyone who wishes to accept it. We don't know who the artist is, no one has recorded his name, but the insight he (or she) gives in this painting is profound.
Those who like to keep things according to the written word would argue for a yes. However, it isn't quite so simple or straight forward. There are a number of things NOT said in the Gospel accounts for various reasons, among them the fact that the writers didn't expect anyone to be reading this who didn't "know" certain important cultural things about such a meal. Second, you didn't waste valuable papyrus writing down what they perceived to be unimportant details, so here goes the first little hand grenade.
The Gospel accounts don't tell us who else was at the table, and names only the key figures. We know, from other sources, that the "Upper Room" was in the house of the parents of John Mark, the writer of the shortest Gospel, and he actually directs his readers to other witnesses then alive who could confirm what he wrote. He wasn't one of the twelve either, at the time he was a teenager - the 'youth' who followed the twelve and Jesus to the Garden of Gethsemane wrapped only in his blanket - and ran away naked when the soldiers tried to arrest him. Why doesn't he mention the Supper was in his parents' house? He didn't need to - everyone knew.
The next bit, is equally important. This was either an Eve of Sabbath meal, or an Eve of Passover meal in a Jewish household. You cannot hold either without sharing it with the entire family, and in the second case, your neighbours and their families, the servants and the children! So, I offer MY version of the Last Supper for argument -
Breaking of Bread.
I'm no Leonardo, but I would like to think this version of The Last Supper, with the wives, daughters and children present is closer to the real event than the more literal interpretations by better painters. What we in Christendom ignore, overlook or fail to recognise is that in a Jewish household the Eve of Sabbath meal begins with the women bring lights to the table, the head of the house then give thanks for the food and breaks and shares the bread. Present are all the household, it is unthinkable for it to be 'men only' and the meal ends with the blessing (usually by the eldest son of the household) and sharing of a cup of wine. Recognise the pattern?I post this since there is currently a huge row in many Christian churches over the role of women, usually founded on the argument "they weren't present at the Last Supper" or "they weren't selected, ordained or commissioned by Jesus". I'd suggest you read those passages again very carefully - and try to see what is not there "because you would know that".
The second picture is Medieval. It can be seen in Tewkesbury Abbey and adorns the wall of the Trinity Chapel, possibly more famous for the "Kneeling Knight" (supposedly Edward Despenser) on the roof. The painting survived the Iconoclasts largely because it was hidden from view by a wooden screen, though sadly the lower portion of it didn't survive the whitewash of the later puritan tenants. It depicts the Trinity, that stumbling block for Christians and non-Christians alike, and it shows the answer to Christ's question from the cross. Look closely at this wonderful depiction -
It depicts the figure of the Father holding the crucified Son, with the dove of the Holy Spirit between the two. The answer you seek is this - Christ's question was; Why have you forsaken me? The answer is shown here.
I have not forsaken you, I am holding you in my hands.
It depicts the offering of himself, in the form of Jesus that God the Creator and Father has made, and in the Holy Spirit continues to offer in love and grace to anyone and everyone who wishes to accept it. We don't know who the artist is, no one has recorded his name, but the insight he (or she) gives in this painting is profound.
Saturday, 5 October 2013
The Young Person's Guide to the SATB Choir
The SATB Choir is the standard formation for choral work in most Churches, Oratarios and major classical works, and it does have a full, rich sound to it. But, how does it work, and how is it composed? I found the following recently thanks to a friend. I'm unashamedly reposting it here.
I'll confess to being a totally untrained Bass, often used as a 'filler' in a chorus (to make up the volume) who could, once, reach the lowest part of the Bass 'range' (Bottom F) but always struggled to get above Middle C ... Made it interesting leading worship sometimes!
THE YOUNG PERSON'S GUIDE TO THE SATB CHOIR In any chorus, there are four voice parts: soprano, alto, tenor, and bass. Sometimes these are divided into first and second within each part, prompting endless jokes about first and second basses. There are also various other parts such as baritone, countertenor, contralto, mezzo soprano, etc., but these are mostly used by people who are either soloists, or belong to some excessively hotshot classical a cappella group (this applies especially to countertenors), or are trying to make excuses for not really fitting into any of the regular voice parts, so we will ignore them for now.Source: Choir Jokes from Comedy Corner
Each voice part sings in a different range, and each one has a very different personality. You may ask, "Why should singing different notes make people act differently?", and indeed this is a mysterious question and has not been adequately studied, especially since scientists who study musicians tend to be musicians themselves and have all the peculiar complexes that go with being tenors, french horn players, timpanists, or whatever. However, this is beside the point; the fact remains that the four voice parts can be easily distinguished, and I will now explain how.
THE SOPRANOS are the ones who sing the highest, and because of this they think they rule the world. They have longer hair, fancier jewelry, and swishier skirts than anyone else, and they consider themselves insulted if they are not allowed to go at least to a high F in every movement of any given piece. When they reach the high notes, they hold them for at least half again as long as the composer and/or conductor requires, and then complain that their throats are killing them and that the composer and conductor are sadists. Sopranos have varied attitudes toward the other sections of the chorus, though they consider all of them inferior. Altos are to sopranos rather like second violins to first violins - nice to harmonize with, but not really necessary. All sopranos have a secret feeling that the altos could drop out and the piece would sound essentially the same, and they don't understand why anybody would sing in that range in the first place - it's so boring. Tenors, on the other hand, can be very nice to have around; besides their flirtation possibilities (it is a well-known fact that sopranos never flirt with basses), sopranos like to sing duets with tenors because all the tenors are doing is working very hard to sing in a low-to-medium soprano range, while the sopranos are up there in the stratosphere showing off. To sopranos, basses are the scum of the earth - they sing too damn loud, are useless to tune to because they're down in that low, low range - and there has to be something wrong with anyone who sings in the F clef, anyway.
THE ALTOS are the salt of the earth - in their opinion, at least. Altos are unassuming people, who would wear jeans to concerts if they were allowed to. Altos are in a unique position in the chorus in that they are unable to complain about having to sing either very high or very low, and they know that all the other sections think their parts are pitifully easy. But the altos know otherwise. They know that while the sopranos are screeching away on a high A, they are being forced to sing elaborate passages full of sharps and flats and tricks of rhythm, and nobody is noticing because the sopranos are singing too loud (and the basses usually are too). Altos get a deep, secret pleasure out of conspiring together to tune the sopranos flat. Altos have an innate distrust of tenors, because the tenors sing in almost the same range and think they sound better. They like the basses, and enjoy singing duets with them - the basses just sound like a rumble anyway, and it's the only time the altos can really be heard. Altos' other complaint is that there are always too many of them and so they never get to sing really loud.
THE TENORS are spoiled. That's all there is to it. For one thing, there are never enough of them, and choir directors would rather sell their souls than let a halfway decent tenor quit, while they're always ready to unload a few altos at half price. And then, for some reason, the few tenors there are are always really good - it's one of those annoying facts of life.. So it's no wonder that tenors always get swollen heads - after all, who else can make sopranos swoon? The one thing that can make tenors insecure is the accusation (usually by the basses) that anyone singing that high couldn't possibly be a real man.. In their usual perverse fashion, the tenors never acknowledge this, but just complain louder about the composer being a sadist and making them sing so damn high. Tenors have a love-hate relationship with the conductor, too, because the conductor is always telling them to sing louder because there are so few of them. No conductor in recorded history has ever asked for less tenor in a forte passage. Tenors feel threatened in some way by all the other sections - the sopranos because they can hit those incredibly high notes; the altos because they have no trouble singing the notes the tenors kill themselves for; and the basses because, although they can't sing anything above an E, they sing it loud enough to drown the tenors out. Of course, the tenors would rather die than admit any of this. It is a little-known fact that tenors move their eyebrows more than anyone else while singing.
THE BASSES sing the lowest of anybody. This basically explains everything. They are stolid, dependable people, and have more facial hair than anybody else. The basses feel perpetually unappreciated, but they have a deep conviction that they are actually the most important part (a view endorsed by musicologists, but certainly not by sopranos or tenors), despite the fact that they have the most boring part of anybody and often sing the same note (or in endless fifths) for an entire page. They compensate for this by singing as loudly as they can get away with - most basses are tuba players at heart. Basses are the only section that can regularly complain about how low their part is, and they make horrible faces when trying to hit very low notes. Basses are charitable people, but their charity does not extend so far as tenors, whom they consider effete poseurs. Basses hate tuning the tenors more than almost anything else. Basses like altos - except when they have duets and the altos get the good part. As for the sopranos, they are simply in an alternate universe which the basses don't understand at all. They can't imagine why anybody would ever want to sing that high and sound that bad when they make mistakes. When a bass makes a mistake, the other three parts will cover him, and he can continue on his merry way, knowing that sometime, somehow, he will end up at the root of the chord.
I'll confess to being a totally untrained Bass, often used as a 'filler' in a chorus (to make up the volume) who could, once, reach the lowest part of the Bass 'range' (Bottom F) but always struggled to get above Middle C ... Made it interesting leading worship sometimes!
Friday, 4 October 2013
How NOT to make Law ...
I have been watching the 'shut down' of the US Federal government with something akin to astonishment. I confess, that based on the Huff Post reports and the BBC it seemed, at the very least, as if there was some deliberate 'self-destruct' intention at work in their Congress. Why would any party refuse to pass a budget to keep government services running? What really does lie behind this impassioned response to funding the "Obamacare" plan? Digging around, and asking some direct questions of a few of my US contacts has turned up some answers that leave me wondering if the US legislators actually understand democracy at all!
Let's start with the Act at the centre of this row. Obamacare, the proper title is The Patient Care and Affordable Care Act, is an astonishingly hefty tome, I'm told over a thousand pages in length. It was presented to Congress, unread and unseen, and Congress was given precisely 24 hours to pass it. Pardon? Pass a complex Bill of a thousand pages in one 24 hour sitting? That is precisely what was done. Immediately before the 2011 election and while the Democrats had small majorities in the Congress. The then Speaker, Democrat Nancy Pelosi, told those who objected, I quote, "You have to pass this Bill to be able to read what's in it."
I'm sorry, but had I been an elected member I would have refused to vote. Or I would have voted "No". It is just plain irresponsible to move, accept and adopt something as far reaching and as politically important as this without knowing precisely what is and what is not provided for by it. There is no way such an Bill can be read in just 24 hours! Yet this is exactly how the Congress was railroaded into passing the Bill. And now they are reaping the result.
Having learned this, and I have learned that such tactics are by no means unique, I find myself appalled by it. The US is always held up as the 'model' of western democracy, yet, in passing legislation in this manner, it is employing tactics used in the Soviet Union and in Communist China under Stalin and Mao. This is not western democratic process, this isn't good practice and it makes for appalling laws. If this is the 'model' of democracy they are following, I am not at all surprised the US has got itself into the mess it has. Nowhere in the world (apart from certain already mentioned dictatorships) can complex Bills be tabled, unread, unopposed, and adopted in 24 hours. In Britain, it would take up to three years to get legislation like this through the Houses of Parliament, because part of the democratic process is to allow public consultation, multiple reviews, revision of the text, judicial reviews, scrutiny by both Houses and finally it emerges as an Act. You cannot claim to be making good laws when you throw a thousand page document at the House, tell them to pass it, and then read it. That is a travesty. It is NOT democracy at work, that is playing ideological games.
Interestingly, I am also told that the reason Congress has at last bared its teeth is that many of its members face re-election next year. The President doesn't. He no longer, in the words of Ret Butler in Gone with the Wind, "gives a damn." He's now in the happy position of not having to bother about what the electorate will say or do come election day. The Members of Congress do - and, from what I am told, the impact of the Bill on the voters is starting to bite and to produce some very angry voters. I expect I would be too, if I was being told that my existing Health Care Plan was going to cost me 2 to 3 times what it used to cost, or that I must now pay the first $5,000 of any major treatment. Yet that is what is happening. Obama has also 'rewarded' Congress by exempting them from the provisions of the Bill and around 1,200 other institutions and large donor concerns, but the small businesses are being crippled by it. If you employ fifty or more people you must provide a Health Care Scheme. The cost to employers has been hiked by the Insurance providers, so, again as I suspect I would be forced to do, businesses on that threshold, are cutting staff.
Contrary to what a lot of the commentators outside the US seem to think, Obamacare is NOT about providing a National Health Service. It is about compelling people to buy Health Insurance. Those in work, in employers schemes or in private schemes are being made to pay more in order to fund those not in work. It is now illegal to NOT take out Health insurance according to my source, and that is hurting a lot of folk on low wages.
I remain astonished and appalled by the manner in which the US is dealing with the 'Debt Freeze' (although it isn't unique either I discovered, there have been 17 of these in the last few decades, at least 15 caused by the Democrats refusing to pass budgets under Republican Administrations). I am even more appalled by the manner in which the nation that purports to be the leader of the democratic world makes its laws. I accept that the Bill was not drafted in total secrecy, there must be some mechanism of consultation involved, but there does seem to be no mechanism for agreement on amendments or changes during the process. One thousand page documents are not written overnight, and Congress should never be allowed to pass one without the members having read it carefully. Twenty-four hours to read, consider, discuss, amend and then adopt one? No way.
I can only hope that this cavalier approach to creating legislation will now be revisited and revised. Europe, the UK and several other states could probably provide the US with much more workable, democratic and reasonable models. Would someone please persuade them to adopt one!
Let's start with the Act at the centre of this row. Obamacare, the proper title is The Patient Care and Affordable Care Act, is an astonishingly hefty tome, I'm told over a thousand pages in length. It was presented to Congress, unread and unseen, and Congress was given precisely 24 hours to pass it. Pardon? Pass a complex Bill of a thousand pages in one 24 hour sitting? That is precisely what was done. Immediately before the 2011 election and while the Democrats had small majorities in the Congress. The then Speaker, Democrat Nancy Pelosi, told those who objected, I quote, "You have to pass this Bill to be able to read what's in it."
I'm sorry, but had I been an elected member I would have refused to vote. Or I would have voted "No". It is just plain irresponsible to move, accept and adopt something as far reaching and as politically important as this without knowing precisely what is and what is not provided for by it. There is no way such an Bill can be read in just 24 hours! Yet this is exactly how the Congress was railroaded into passing the Bill. And now they are reaping the result.
Having learned this, and I have learned that such tactics are by no means unique, I find myself appalled by it. The US is always held up as the 'model' of western democracy, yet, in passing legislation in this manner, it is employing tactics used in the Soviet Union and in Communist China under Stalin and Mao. This is not western democratic process, this isn't good practice and it makes for appalling laws. If this is the 'model' of democracy they are following, I am not at all surprised the US has got itself into the mess it has. Nowhere in the world (apart from certain already mentioned dictatorships) can complex Bills be tabled, unread, unopposed, and adopted in 24 hours. In Britain, it would take up to three years to get legislation like this through the Houses of Parliament, because part of the democratic process is to allow public consultation, multiple reviews, revision of the text, judicial reviews, scrutiny by both Houses and finally it emerges as an Act. You cannot claim to be making good laws when you throw a thousand page document at the House, tell them to pass it, and then read it. That is a travesty. It is NOT democracy at work, that is playing ideological games.
Interestingly, I am also told that the reason Congress has at last bared its teeth is that many of its members face re-election next year. The President doesn't. He no longer, in the words of Ret Butler in Gone with the Wind, "gives a damn." He's now in the happy position of not having to bother about what the electorate will say or do come election day. The Members of Congress do - and, from what I am told, the impact of the Bill on the voters is starting to bite and to produce some very angry voters. I expect I would be too, if I was being told that my existing Health Care Plan was going to cost me 2 to 3 times what it used to cost, or that I must now pay the first $5,000 of any major treatment. Yet that is what is happening. Obama has also 'rewarded' Congress by exempting them from the provisions of the Bill and around 1,200 other institutions and large donor concerns, but the small businesses are being crippled by it. If you employ fifty or more people you must provide a Health Care Scheme. The cost to employers has been hiked by the Insurance providers, so, again as I suspect I would be forced to do, businesses on that threshold, are cutting staff.
Contrary to what a lot of the commentators outside the US seem to think, Obamacare is NOT about providing a National Health Service. It is about compelling people to buy Health Insurance. Those in work, in employers schemes or in private schemes are being made to pay more in order to fund those not in work. It is now illegal to NOT take out Health insurance according to my source, and that is hurting a lot of folk on low wages.
I remain astonished and appalled by the manner in which the US is dealing with the 'Debt Freeze' (although it isn't unique either I discovered, there have been 17 of these in the last few decades, at least 15 caused by the Democrats refusing to pass budgets under Republican Administrations). I am even more appalled by the manner in which the nation that purports to be the leader of the democratic world makes its laws. I accept that the Bill was not drafted in total secrecy, there must be some mechanism of consultation involved, but there does seem to be no mechanism for agreement on amendments or changes during the process. One thousand page documents are not written overnight, and Congress should never be allowed to pass one without the members having read it carefully. Twenty-four hours to read, consider, discuss, amend and then adopt one? No way.
I can only hope that this cavalier approach to creating legislation will now be revisited and revised. Europe, the UK and several other states could probably provide the US with much more workable, democratic and reasonable models. Would someone please persuade them to adopt one!
Thursday, 3 October 2013
German Day of Unity
Today is a public holiday in Germany, the celebration of the reunification of West and East Germany in 1991. The radio has had some interesting reflections of how Germany came into being, the post World War 1 economic and political chaos which gave rise to Hitler and his thugs, and finally the partition between the Allies and the Russians. As I am listening to the biography of Joachim Gauck, the current Bundespraesident, it has provided a a very interesting background to his memoir of life under the Soviets and their puppets, the German Democratic Socialists ...
I have come to believe, reading several recent histories, and rereading some of those I am more familiar with, that a unified Germany is far better for modern Europe than the divided one the west and the eastern powers kept alive for forty years. I can never understand those who persist in thinking the East was a 'model' state, or that socialism, communism, Marxism (which Marx himself wouldn't recognise) or any of the other Left-wing "-isms" is either fair, just or viable. It must be ironic that we currently have the Greens veering even further Left, and the former Communists trying to present themselves as "good guys". The voters rejected this in the elections, both the Greens and the Left lost ground, the Social Democrats held their share - just.
Germany is not some armed camp lurking in the heart of Europe waiting for an opportunity to seize control of everyone else. It is a nation of hardworking people, who remember their past and refuse to let the extremists take them down that road again. The modern Germany is working hard to preserve stability, and to make Europe secure.
Personally, I hope they succeed. They've had everyone tramp across their country for centuries, and they have learned from it. They prize stability above all else, and they're prepared to work to keep it.
I have come to believe, reading several recent histories, and rereading some of those I am more familiar with, that a unified Germany is far better for modern Europe than the divided one the west and the eastern powers kept alive for forty years. I can never understand those who persist in thinking the East was a 'model' state, or that socialism, communism, Marxism (which Marx himself wouldn't recognise) or any of the other Left-wing "-isms" is either fair, just or viable. It must be ironic that we currently have the Greens veering even further Left, and the former Communists trying to present themselves as "good guys". The voters rejected this in the elections, both the Greens and the Left lost ground, the Social Democrats held their share - just.
Germany is not some armed camp lurking in the heart of Europe waiting for an opportunity to seize control of everyone else. It is a nation of hardworking people, who remember their past and refuse to let the extremists take them down that road again. The modern Germany is working hard to preserve stability, and to make Europe secure.
Personally, I hope they succeed. They've had everyone tramp across their country for centuries, and they have learned from it. They prize stability above all else, and they're prepared to work to keep it.
Wednesday, 2 October 2013
The Passage of Time ...
Today the Monk finds himself wondering where the years went. He looks back on a very full, sometimes rewarding, often hectic and sometimes bitter range of experiences. The high points in his life were the births of his three children (in which he had a very minor role ...), his career, the move to the UK in 1988 and the subsequent time he spent in various ministry roles culminating in his time in the congregation and ministry of Tewkesbury Abbey.
Today his wife has spoiled him. Her gift is a 'smart phone' for him, so now he must learn to use it properly - and remember to convey to all his friends, the new number!
Now his faithful small companion is waiting for his all important walk in the woods with the Monk. Harry has to check all his marker posts, check which new deer, wild boar, other dogs and even the odd raccoon or pine marten has dared to wander through his forest, so the Monk had best make haste and set off.
Today his wife has spoiled him. Her gift is a 'smart phone' for him, so now he must learn to use it properly - and remember to convey to all his friends, the new number!
Now his faithful small companion is waiting for his all important walk in the woods with the Monk. Harry has to check all his marker posts, check which new deer, wild boar, other dogs and even the odd raccoon or pine marten has dared to wander through his forest, so the Monk had best make haste and set off.
Tuesday, 1 October 2013
Looking After Number 1 ...
Following on from yesterday's post, I have to make some comment on the state of the western democracies in the light of the economic decisions and activities as I see them at present. Watching a televised debate last night on German television several things leapt out at me. Firstly, the German economy is currently strong and this is, in part, because the labour market is largely free. People negotiate their wage levels with their employer, not with some national minimum in mind. It has led to a situation where there are lots of "mini-jobs" and many on the lower end of the pay scales hold down two and even three such hourly paid jobs. Secondly it is because, with some notable exceptions, the employers and the unions work together and not in opposition.
The exceptions are the "international" employers and the "state" owned (or the state has a major share and say in the running of them) companies. Here the pattern is confrontational, and one does have to wonder why. The debate last night highlighted at least one reason. One of the debaters was a passionate lady from Die Linke, the former Communist "Socialist Unity Party for Germany" which ran the East German State with an iron fist, secret police, guns, walls, fences and all. She provided, for me, the perfect example of the passionate ideologue with little or no experience (or contact with) the realities of the world or the lives of the people she claims to wish to "improve". Her passionate interuptions, tirades and denunciations of everything and everyone who dared to say anything she disagreed with was evidence enough of her inability to recognise any other point of view, but it was compounded by her emphatic stance on the position of tax and ownership.
On the first, she was adamant that everyone had to pay more tax so that the infrastructure, the schools, the nursery places, health care and virtually everything else could be "improved" according to her ideal. She became extremely aggitated when it was pointed out that a large portion of the crumbling infrastructure lay in the parts of Germany her party had run for over 40 years and failed to improve. That the shortage of money for this everywhere in the western parts now is largely the result of it having to be prioritised to bring the eastern Lände up to standard. For me this highlighted the political divide across the west, between the well-to-do "socialists" who see themselves as "liberal, enlightened and benevolent" and driven by the desire to create a "fair" society in which, presumably, everyone enjoys a "fair" division of wealth. The trouble is, that their idea of "fair" usually means they keep the power and the wealth, and the rest of us get to share what they determine to be the appropriate reward we "deserve". On the second point she was ambiguous and rather evasive, but the implication was that her party believed they should have a say in who had what.
On the other hand at present we have the "conservative" politicians who are perhaps better described as "monetarists" and want a society in which tax is low (most of us would say we want that), government is small and less intrusive and they and their cronies, supporters and camp-followers are free to reap uncapped and unrestricted rewards. Of course they also believe that some of the wealth needs to be directed to keeping the less fortunate from the barricades and to maintaining infrastructures. After all, what is the point of owning a Jaguar or a Bentley if you can't drive it on the roads, or the airport terminal is falling apart and you can't actually use it to get to your First Class seat for that holiday on a private island? People notice if the lights go out because the power lines fell down, or the gas stops flowing through the pipes because the gas mains are broken. So they tend to spend just enough to keep that from happening, and by shuffling the cups (round and round they go - where the pea is no one knows) you can keep people from noticing that the pea is actually shrinking.
It may well be true (and I certainly believe it is) that our civil services have become bloated and that the senior elements of it are way overpaid, that our politicians are lining their pockets at our expense, but then, it has ever been thus. A simple reading of the tales of the corruption in the corridors of power in the 17th to 19th Centuries - which led to the creation of the civil service as we know it in the first place - to realise that the wheel has turned full circle and we are back to a very similar state. The corruption is less visible, but just as in the 18th Century contracts were handed out to cronies and friends, now they go to "preferred bidders" with gold plated get out clauses and inflated bids. The whole thing runs, as has been exposed in a number of political biographies recently, on a very selective and very closed network. One that runs not only through the upper echelons of Westminster, but through Whitehall and on into the major companies of the commercial, mercantile and industrial side as well. If you aren't in that network from the start, you'll find a very solid glass ceiling in place - unless you've the money to buy your way round it.
That network is the key to power and the real wealth of most western nations. One needs patronage, one needs the right contacts. One needs that all important "nod" from the right heads to gain access. A single "black ball" and you're out, forever on the periphery. It's a fact of life in the corridors of power, but even insiders can fall out of the net. As one very senior civil servant once confided at a dinner I was Master of Ceremonies for, "the way to survive in Whitehall is to be THE expert on some 'problem'. You must never offer a solution, just be THE person who everyone has to consult if they need to know anything about the problem." He went on to explain that sometimes one had to 'create' a problem ...
To this must be added a new phenomenon in Whitehall/Westminster - the Special Adviser. These individuals are usually students of political 'science' and are hired at marvelous salaries to 'advise' ministers on specific subjects. Some are straight from university, activists with a passion for some single issue, full of 'factoids' about that issue, but with little grasp of anything beyond it, or indeed, of any of the impacts adopting their preferred solution will bring. Thus we have the Chief Scientist being told by an impassioned non-scientist how ecologically unsound it is to use a diesel car. This, despite the said scientist explaining that the diesel car is more economical and less ecologically damaging to manufacture and run than the alternative hybrid whose batteries have a life span of five years. These cannot be recycled and the manufacture of them produces some really toxic and ecologically damaging wastes - which cannot be reprocessed.
Then one looks at where the SpAd came from and who his/her connections are and, surprise, surprise, there's a network connection through school, university, Party and possibly even family. That is the bottom line unfortunately. The Whitehall/Westminster/City network has existed for centuries and it exists in one form or anther in every country, no matter the ideological flavour of the government. It exists for one reason only, to preserve those in the "Upper Ten Thousand" (the classic 1%) in their positions of power and wealth, and to make sure their dynastic successors remain in it.
Can we change it? Probably not, since destroying one such network will simply give rise to a new one. The best way to deal with it is to learn the rules of this game, and then play it to your own advantage, not always the easiest thing to do, and probably a very selfish view. Better still, in my view, is to play the game, but with a moral and honest view to sharing the reward. That, perhaps, is what the political class is not prepared to do.
The exceptions are the "international" employers and the "state" owned (or the state has a major share and say in the running of them) companies. Here the pattern is confrontational, and one does have to wonder why. The debate last night highlighted at least one reason. One of the debaters was a passionate lady from Die Linke, the former Communist "Socialist Unity Party for Germany" which ran the East German State with an iron fist, secret police, guns, walls, fences and all. She provided, for me, the perfect example of the passionate ideologue with little or no experience (or contact with) the realities of the world or the lives of the people she claims to wish to "improve". Her passionate interuptions, tirades and denunciations of everything and everyone who dared to say anything she disagreed with was evidence enough of her inability to recognise any other point of view, but it was compounded by her emphatic stance on the position of tax and ownership.
On the first, she was adamant that everyone had to pay more tax so that the infrastructure, the schools, the nursery places, health care and virtually everything else could be "improved" according to her ideal. She became extremely aggitated when it was pointed out that a large portion of the crumbling infrastructure lay in the parts of Germany her party had run for over 40 years and failed to improve. That the shortage of money for this everywhere in the western parts now is largely the result of it having to be prioritised to bring the eastern Lände up to standard. For me this highlighted the political divide across the west, between the well-to-do "socialists" who see themselves as "liberal, enlightened and benevolent" and driven by the desire to create a "fair" society in which, presumably, everyone enjoys a "fair" division of wealth. The trouble is, that their idea of "fair" usually means they keep the power and the wealth, and the rest of us get to share what they determine to be the appropriate reward we "deserve". On the second point she was ambiguous and rather evasive, but the implication was that her party believed they should have a say in who had what.
On the other hand at present we have the "conservative" politicians who are perhaps better described as "monetarists" and want a society in which tax is low (most of us would say we want that), government is small and less intrusive and they and their cronies, supporters and camp-followers are free to reap uncapped and unrestricted rewards. Of course they also believe that some of the wealth needs to be directed to keeping the less fortunate from the barricades and to maintaining infrastructures. After all, what is the point of owning a Jaguar or a Bentley if you can't drive it on the roads, or the airport terminal is falling apart and you can't actually use it to get to your First Class seat for that holiday on a private island? People notice if the lights go out because the power lines fell down, or the gas stops flowing through the pipes because the gas mains are broken. So they tend to spend just enough to keep that from happening, and by shuffling the cups (round and round they go - where the pea is no one knows) you can keep people from noticing that the pea is actually shrinking.
It may well be true (and I certainly believe it is) that our civil services have become bloated and that the senior elements of it are way overpaid, that our politicians are lining their pockets at our expense, but then, it has ever been thus. A simple reading of the tales of the corruption in the corridors of power in the 17th to 19th Centuries - which led to the creation of the civil service as we know it in the first place - to realise that the wheel has turned full circle and we are back to a very similar state. The corruption is less visible, but just as in the 18th Century contracts were handed out to cronies and friends, now they go to "preferred bidders" with gold plated get out clauses and inflated bids. The whole thing runs, as has been exposed in a number of political biographies recently, on a very selective and very closed network. One that runs not only through the upper echelons of Westminster, but through Whitehall and on into the major companies of the commercial, mercantile and industrial side as well. If you aren't in that network from the start, you'll find a very solid glass ceiling in place - unless you've the money to buy your way round it.
That network is the key to power and the real wealth of most western nations. One needs patronage, one needs the right contacts. One needs that all important "nod" from the right heads to gain access. A single "black ball" and you're out, forever on the periphery. It's a fact of life in the corridors of power, but even insiders can fall out of the net. As one very senior civil servant once confided at a dinner I was Master of Ceremonies for, "the way to survive in Whitehall is to be THE expert on some 'problem'. You must never offer a solution, just be THE person who everyone has to consult if they need to know anything about the problem." He went on to explain that sometimes one had to 'create' a problem ...
To this must be added a new phenomenon in Whitehall/Westminster - the Special Adviser. These individuals are usually students of political 'science' and are hired at marvelous salaries to 'advise' ministers on specific subjects. Some are straight from university, activists with a passion for some single issue, full of 'factoids' about that issue, but with little grasp of anything beyond it, or indeed, of any of the impacts adopting their preferred solution will bring. Thus we have the Chief Scientist being told by an impassioned non-scientist how ecologically unsound it is to use a diesel car. This, despite the said scientist explaining that the diesel car is more economical and less ecologically damaging to manufacture and run than the alternative hybrid whose batteries have a life span of five years. These cannot be recycled and the manufacture of them produces some really toxic and ecologically damaging wastes - which cannot be reprocessed.
Then one looks at where the SpAd came from and who his/her connections are and, surprise, surprise, there's a network connection through school, university, Party and possibly even family. That is the bottom line unfortunately. The Whitehall/Westminster/City network has existed for centuries and it exists in one form or anther in every country, no matter the ideological flavour of the government. It exists for one reason only, to preserve those in the "Upper Ten Thousand" (the classic 1%) in their positions of power and wealth, and to make sure their dynastic successors remain in it.
Can we change it? Probably not, since destroying one such network will simply give rise to a new one. The best way to deal with it is to learn the rules of this game, and then play it to your own advantage, not always the easiest thing to do, and probably a very selfish view. Better still, in my view, is to play the game, but with a moral and honest view to sharing the reward. That, perhaps, is what the political class is not prepared to do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
